I think I just died.

[PurplPanda]

Omg. I just read the story about Penny and Tom Nook and Billy and omg I just died. If you haven't read it, read it here. Be warned, it's frickin scary.

 

[Mariah]

The Terrible Secret of Animal Crossing? You found that scary? Are you under the age of seven?

 

[Alice]

The Terrible Secret of Animal Crossing? You found that scary? Are you under the age of seven?

I concur, well, with the whole note being scary part. Penny was a bit offputting, but the story in general was more of a thriller than a horror story

 

[Bowie]

The Terrible Secret of Animal Crossing? You found that scary? Are you under the age of seven?

There's no reason to mock people.

 

[JellyDitto]

It wasn't THAT scary... The only frightening thing about it was penny with her skin torn off.

 

[Titi]

I skimmed through it the other day.
It's creative and well written, but I wouldn't say it was scary.
On the creepy side for sure!
The story was pretty original though.

 

[dreamysnowx]

That was one hell of a story! Really enjoyed it, makes me look at animal crossing in a weird way now. :c

 

[Kildor]

Not scary. Creepy yes, but scary? Not really. It has some strong language that was quite out of place, but it was well-written.

 

[Mewmewmewm]

Blarg. Don't remind me of Penny's creepy face XD

for me, i have a really weird things with eyes. When i was 5 i had to get eye surgery and eyes have freaked me out eversince. It makes me squeamish even talking about them now, so you can imagine my reaction to Penny's face （；＿；）
Wouldn't say its scary, but DANG was it disturbing （≧∇≦）

 

[WatashiWantsWaffles]

Yeah, read most of it today. The drawings are very good, I think

 

[Alice]

There's no reason to mock people.

You're talking to Mariah here.

 

[Sloom]

There's no reason to mock people.

^ Yeah

I didn't read it all but some of it actually made me lol (No offense there might have been a really scary bit at the end) and really, it needs to be a video to be scary, watch sonic.exe and die of disgust and terror (Well at least I did)

 

[Idfldnsndt]

:0 my name is Billy D:

 

[Waluigi]

Not scary. Another creepypasta (supose it can be called creepypasta) to add to the crappypasta section.

At least its better than sonic.exe. Thats the worst creepypasta ever.

 

[Alice]

^ Yeah

I didn't read it all but some of it actually made me lol (No offense there might have been a really scary bit at the end) and really, it needs to be a video to be scary, watch sonic.exe and die of disgust and terror (Well at least I did)

Sonic.exe isn't really all that scary either. Anything with too much blood in it is automatically hilarous. Back in the day, Bendrowned had some pretty creepy footage.

 

[Idfldnsndt]

Sonic.exe isn't really all that scary either. Anything with too much blood in it is automatically hilarous. Back in the day, Bendrowned had some pretty creepy footage.

Ayyyy you shouldn't have done that.

 

[PurplPanda]

Not scary. Creepy yes, but scary? Not really. It has some strong language that was quite out of place, but it was well-written.

I meant creepy, not scary. I was creeped out, I guess I just assumed everyone would get my message. I don't like organs and blood and stuff and it was bad for me in that way.

 

[Kildor]

Sonic.exe= Not scary
TSoAC=Not scary
Any creepypasta with .exe in it=Not scary

The .exe is way too overused. I find most creepy pastas creepy, but Candle Cove is what freaks me the **** out.

 

[poliwag0]

My dog, Penny is offended.
Also it wasnt scary, it was just like "blooddecapitationeyesmurderDEATH!!!!!!1!!soscaryomg!!1!!!!"

 

[Big Forum User]

I liked it... I wasn't scared, but I rather enjoyed it!