I have too many Peppy villagers, which one should I keep?

[TheGreatBrain]

I like them all, but Merry is one of my all time favorites.

 

[wolfie1]

Based off of my personal experience with Cheri, I'd choose her. Cookie is cute too, though.

 

[davidlblack]

This will be a difficult decision...

It seems like everyone is basing their vote on looks. Normally I like my villagers even if they aren't the cutest... but okey.

 

[Venn]

I would keep Cookie!

 

[padfoot6]

I'd say keep Cookie c: If you have her a pastel town she'd fit in really well too

 

[ashnoona]

I'm actually moving out Melba for Cheri cx
I already have Bunnie and i love her. But among your three, I'd keep Cheri.
Im not a fan of the cats and dogs in ACNL c:

 

[ZetaFunction]

In my opinion, you should keep Cookie. I used to have Cookie in my town, but I lost her a couple months ago. She originally came and smashed some of my hybrids, and plotted right next to my house, but after awhile she grew on me, and I'm finally starting to miss her.

 

[davidlblack]

Cookie asked to move... should i let her go guys?

 

[GalacticGhost]

i think you should keep merry. i've had her, and she's great!

 

[MTPockets]

I would keep Cheri or Cookie. I've never been a fan of Merry.

 

[GTsTentacleChow]

I'd choose either Cheri or Merry, mostly because I'm not a personal fan of Cookie, but honestly, you should choose whoever you feel closest to in game!

 

[Plupap]

Merry is super underrated. Keep her.