Help with snooty villagers!

[Globes216]

I have 3 snooty villagers Blaire, Tasha and Ankha and one of every other type. I feel like having 3 snooty villagers might be too much but it is my favourite personality. I would like to get rid of one for another villager (preferably Sherb) but idk who to remove. I have reasons for liking all of them..

Blaire - my favourite villager from when I played wild world as a kid. I never managed to get her in New Leaf so when she came to my campsite I was ecstatic to see her. I have a lot of love for her from my wild world days way back when. However, keeping her means I would have two squirrels with Tasha, my only repeat species.

Tasha - I've never had her before but I love her design and her house (that wallpaper!!) I love her skunk aesthetic and squirrels are my favourite species. But once again I would have repeat species and I like a bit of diversity

Ankha - I found her randomly while island hopping for Sherb and I couldn't pass up! Ive never had her before either and her look is really cool. Shes the only cat on my island and since I love the cats so much I feel like I need one on my island. Unfortunately I don't like her house interior (seriously no bed or anything just a big pyramid and a golden toilet) and her house exterior isn't the most appealing for my town aesthetic.

If you could vote on the poll who you would get rid of based on these reasons I'd be very grateful I so wish they bumped the villager limit up to 12 even...

 

[Insulaire]

For what it's worth, all three have different interests (Fashion, Fitness, and Nature) and Tasha has a different response tree and voice pitch from the other two, so I'd definitely keep her and then pick one of the other two-- but there may be enough differences to justify keeping all three if you like them!

 

[starlightsong]

I voted for Ankha because of how she doesn’t fit as well with your aesthetic and you seem to like Tasha better, but I’m actually a bit torn because you say you love the cats and she’s your only one. I would like to say though, Blaire and Tasha may be the same species but it’s not like they look exactly the same, so personally I’d be okay with 2 of the same species! I definitely don’t think you should get rid of Blaire when she’s your favorite villager. So I guess one thing to think about would be, what’s more important to you: having a cat and avoiding double squirrels, or having a villager whose house you love and think fits well on your island? If it’s the first one then get rid of Tasha, if it’s the second get rid of Ankha.

 

[Le Ham]

I feel like you want a cat villager, but maybe Ankha is not the one for you, based on being inconsistent with your town aesthetic like you said. There are 4 other snooty cats - of them I personally think Purrl or even Olivia is really cute, to offer my uninformed opinion as I'm not looking at their subtypes or interiors or anything.

Childhood favorite vs the cool one? I think in the long run the childhood favorite would win out, since you don't want two squirrels. So my vote is let Tasha go and then look for another cat you like better than Ankha.

Post automatically merged: May 5, 2020

Edit to add: I mean that in the short term you could let Tasha go and then a second project over the long term would be to replace Ankha. But I am making an assumption you're willing to go through that search for the other cat, which you understandably might not be!

 

[starlightsong]

I feel like you want a cat villager, but maybe Ankha is not the one for you, based on being inconsistent with your town aesthetic like you said. There are 4 other snooty cats - of them I personally think Purrl or even Olivia is really cute, to offer my uninformed opinion as I'm not looking at their subtypes or interiors or anything.

Childhood favorite vs the cool one? I think in the long run the childhood favorite would win out, since you don't want two squirrels. So my vote is let Tasha go and then look for another cat you like better than Ankha.

I hadn’t considered this in my response but Purrl and Olivia are both adorable! Just gonna share these, both to potentially help the OP and in case you’re curious:

Sadly I don’t have a screenshot of Olivia’s exterior, but she and Purrl both have gorgeous interiors imo. Though I’m biased toward Olivia’s because of the purple.

 

[Globes216]

For what it's worth, all three have different interests (Fashion, Fitness, and Nature) and Tasha has a different response tree and voice pitch from the other two, so I'd definitely keep her and then pick one of the other two-- but there may be enough differences to justify keeping all three if you like them!

Thanks for commenting this! I didn’t actually know that there was response trees so this is really interesting to know! It does make sense though...

Post automatically merged: May 6, 2020

I hadn’t considered this in my response but Purrl and Olivia are both adorable! Just gonna share these, both to potentially help the OP and in case you’re curious:

View attachment 253786View attachment 253787View attachment 253788
Sadly I don’t have a screenshot of Olivia’s exterior, but she and Purrl both have gorgeous interiors imo. Though I’m biased toward Olivia’s because of the purple.

Oh wow Purrls exterior is really nice and I am quite fond of her look. Another villager I’ve never had before!

Post automatically merged: May 6, 2020

I feel like you want a cat villager, but maybe Ankha is not the one for you, based on being inconsistent with your town aesthetic like you said. There are 4 other snooty cats - of them I personally think Purrl or even Olivia is really cute, to offer my uninformed opinion as I'm not looking at their subtypes or interiors or anything.

Childhood favorite vs the cool one? I think in the long run the childhood favorite would win out, since you don't want two squirrels. So my vote is let Tasha go and then look for another cat you like better than Ankha.

Post automatically merged: May 5, 2020

Edit to add: I mean that in the short term you could let Tasha go and then a second project over the long term would be to replace Ankha. But I am making an assumption you're willing to go through that search for the other cat, which you understandably might not be!

Of the snooty cats Kitty is my favourite! She’s one of my top 5 villagers but I had her in almost all my new leaf towns and am trying super hard to resist having her on my island. Although I am super tempted...

 

[voltairenism]

The three of them are my fav snooties and probably my favs female villagers (excluding coco). Don't cut anyone

 

[Blueskyy]

I’d get rid of Ankha. Like someone else said, I prefer Kitty as a snooty cat. Nobody else thinks of her but I think she fits the role well.

 

[cheezu]

Olivia is my favorite snooty cat and there are other ones that I feel are far better like Kitty or Purrl (I also really like Monique though I know she's not popular).
I think she's so elegant.
I'm not a huge fan of Ankha. She's very popular though so you'd easily be able to trade her.

 

[Manon_Despoina]

It seems to me that you should get rid of Ankha and try to get another cat villager in her stead (since you don't seem to like her as much as the rest). I would definitely keep Blaire, because she is your favourite (mine as well in WW! I would really love to have her in my town)... And if you don't want to keep anther squirrel you can also eventually get rid of Tasha so you don't have two of the same species.

 

[Rio_]

This is a really hard choice!

I would definitely keep Blaire since she's one of your childhood favs, especially since you missed out on her in New Leaf!

I really like Tasha's skunk design! You might be able to get around the double squirrel thing if you view her more as a "skunk" villager than a squirrel. But if the repeat thing really bothers you, she might be the choice to let go.

Ankha is super cool (and I love cat villagers so much ;o; ) but between the aesthetic not matching and you not liking her house, I ended up voting for her.

So I would say get rid of Ankha and, like others have suggested, maybe look into one of the other snooty cats if you can't get past the repeat species thing (there are lots of amazing snooty cats <3)

I would also suggest looking up a list of what each of the villager "hobbies" are and see if there are any hobbies you are missing in the rest of your villagers for more variety when everyone is out and about. I wouldn't go solely based off that, but it might help if you're really stuck!