Help With Deciding Villagers

[Bk1234]

I'm thinking of kicking out Hamlet, Tutu, Nana/Tia, Olaf, and Bruce (if I find a better Cranky). Do you guys have any villager recommendations for Jock, Smug, and Cranky, besides the ones on my dreamie list.

~Dreamies~ (That I don't have)
1. Marshal
2. Diana
3. Ankha
4. Raymond

 

[Blueskyy]

Jocks: Dom, Bill
Smug: Kidd, Jacques
Cranky: Dobie, Murphy

 

[Bk1234]

Jocks: Dom, Bill
Smug: Kidd, Jacques
Cranky: Dobie, Murphy

Dobie looks really cool. I actually like his elderly look.

 

[Toasties]

My favourite cranky boys will always be Rolf, Static and Cyd I'd highly recommend them! But I also love Apollo and Wolfgang too!
Jocks I'd say Bam or possibly Tank.
Smug would be Julian, Colton, Lionel or Kidd.

 

[Luella]

Jock: I second Dom because he is hilarious as a jock. Similarly Roald. They both make me laugh.

Smug: I like Shep for looking like an uncle. Zell's design is pretty cool too.

Cranky: Apollo is my current cranky. His hobby is singing which is fun to hear with that deep voice.

 

[Jarrad]

Smug: Kidd
Jock: Bill
Cranky: Tom, Static or Murphy.

 

[Dude_Skillz]

I strongly suggest Butch for a cranky, As he has an adorable face, and the fact that he has the cranky voice is hilarious.

 

[Bk1234]

My favourite cranky boys will always be Rolf, Static and Cyd I'd highly recommend them! But I also love Apollo and Wolfgang too!
Jocks I'd say Bam or possibly Tank.
Smug would be Julian, Colton, Lionel or Kidd.

I actually kicked out Cyd before... But I love Apollo and Wolfgang. Bam is the Jock villager I am hoping for, but I'm open for other suggestions. I had Tank in New Leaf, he was awesome! I really like Lionel's design for some reason

Post automatically merged: Jun 2, 2020

Jock: I second Dom because he is hilarious as a jock. Similarly Roald. They both make me laugh.

View attachment 268850

Smug: I like Shep for looking like an uncle. Zell's design is pretty cool too.

Cranky: Apollo is my current cranky. His hobby is singing which is fun to hear with that deep voice.

That picture of Dom is adorable! ❤

 

[Dude_Skillz]

Butch

 

[Bk1234]

Butch

I do really want a Dog villager... I just don't think he beats Apollo or Wolfgang for me.

Post automatically merged: Jun 2, 2020

I like that these suggestions are giving non mainstream villagers a chance to shine. I don't want my island to have the same group of villagers.

Post automatically merged: Jun 2, 2020

Even though I have Reneigh, Sherb, and Audie...

 

[Xara]

jock: rudy, kid cat, bam

smug: zell, phil, colton, marshal

cranky: dobie, fang, lobo, bruce, tom

 

[Bk1234]

jock: rudy, kid cat, bam

smug: zell, phil, colton, marshal

cranky: dobie, fang, lobo, bruce, tom

I've definitely been considering Kid Cat and Bam. Marshal is in my dreamies list. I really want Fang, actually. He's SO cool! OMG, why have I overlooked him? THANK YOU!!!

Post automatically merged: Jun 2, 2020

Keep the Cranky suggestion coming, but I think I've found one I really like: Fang.

Post automatically merged: Jun 2, 2020

What do you guys think about Lopez?

 

[moon_child]

Jock : Dom, Rudy, Genji
Smug : O Hare
Cranky : Wolfgang, Chief, Fang

 

[Bk1234]

Jock : Dom, Rudy, Genji
Smug : O Hare
Cranky : Wolfgang, Chief, Fang

I love those three Cranky wolves!

 

[Manon_Despoina]

It's a shame you already like Fang, because I wanted to suggest Roscoe! Though I realize his design is not for everyone

For jocks I would recommend either Bill or Rudy!

With regards to Lopez - his design looks really cool and you're right to consider him! Other smugs who I like are O'Hare and Kidd, to just throw my two cents in

 

[Bk1234]

With regards to Lopez - his design looks really cool and you're right to consider him! Other smugs who I like are

Yeah, Lopez, Marshal, and Raymond are probably my Top 3 Smug villager. I would take Kidd but since I have Sherb, I don't really want another goat. (I don't want double villager types, unless I REALLY like the villagers.)

 

[greenvoldemort]

Ooo so many choices for these personalities, some that i like for the jocks include: rudy, ribbot, dom, genji and snake
smug: zell, marshall

 

[InstantNoodles]

These villagers are popular choices and it's easy to see why
Jock: Genji, Snake, Dom
Smug: Julian
Cranky: Apollo, Fang / Wolfgang / Lobo / Dobie (I love all the cranky wolves!)

 

[Tiffany]

Jock-I have Roald and Cobb and they are great. It's so funny hearing them talk about how buff they are while eating a donut
Smug-Shep he's one of my dreamies or Phil he's a cool dude
Cranky-Walt or Lobo both awesome.