Help me decide!

[The Mad Hybrid Botanist]

So right now my current villagers are: Octavian, Julian, Beau, Lolly, Bob, Phil, Fauna, Tabby, Blue Bear, and Buck
The reason I still like Buck is that he is one of my very original villagers. He was nice from day 1 and writes to me mail all the time. I'm not a fan of jock villagers, to be honest, but I feel like if I let him go (especially into the void if no one takes him), I will regret it down the line...
- Only because there is something special about him being nice and always being there. I like that he is neon green but not a particularly big fan of his character design.

I wanted my last spot to go to either an Uchi or Snooty villager, one with a weird design odd-ball design that people usually don't like. I had Diva or Gigi in mind (wanted to try something different). But at the same time idk if I want to get rid of Buck. Any opinions?

Keep Buck? Get Diva? Get Gigi? Decisions Decisions. I'm bad at them.

 

[The Mad Hybrid Botanist]

bump

 

[purple_vixen]

Maybe only let Buck go if someone agrees to take him? I let Tank go in order to meet more characters, but regretted it when no-one wanted him, and he got voided

 

[Rosch]

If Buck has some sort of attachment to you, then I'd say keep him. I might also be bias because I like Jock villagers.

 

[Sheando]

I always vote for keeping villagers you attach to. I think it’s more fun to enjoy the relationships you build instead of obsessing over replacing them for aesthetic purposes.

 

[The Mad Hybrid Botanist]

Okay, guys, I think I will do this! Thanks!!

Post automatically merged: Apr 18, 2020

Aww.

Maybe only let Buck go if someone agrees to take him? I let Tank go in order to meet more characters, but regretted it when no-one wanted him, and he got voided

Post automatically merged: Apr 18, 2020

If Buck has some sort of attachment to you, then I'd say keep him. I might also be bias because I like Jock villagers.

I see.

Post automatically merged: Apr 18, 2020

I always vote for keeping villagers you attach to. I think it’s more fun to enjoy the relationships you build instead of obsessing over replacing them for aesthetic purposes.

I am glad I kept Buck but I still feel on the fence about his design - if he was not an original villager I would not have kept him....I wanted to try Diva or Gigi out.