Help me decide who to keep?

[aimeekitty]

The issue is I need to get rid of two villagers at some point so that I can get one final "dreamie" and 1 lazy (so I have the full personality types?) I'd love a little feedback or opinions.

My town is called Sakura I want it to be cute and soft with a focus on romantic gardens. There is also a zen garden, so a little of an asian flavor. And one of my human character's houses is a host club with restaurants in it.

My villagers that fit the theme:
Flurry (normal white hamster)
Lucy (normal white and pink pig)
Merengue (normal white and pink rhino)
Flora (peppy pink flamingo)
Willow (snooty yellow and pink sheep)
Octavian (cranky red octopus)

I also have:
Ankha (snooty yellow cat)
Shep (smug grey sheepdog)
Mira (Uchi yellow bunny)
Rory (Jock red/brown lion)

Mira and Rory,? they might not perfectly fit the color scheme and theme but I like them better than the others of their personality class I think. You could say that Rory looks like a Chinese lion so fits in with the restaurants and slightly asian flavor? and Mira looks like Sailor Venus, soooo...

I'm thinking if I really want Julian that I might want to let Shep go since they are both Smug? I'm guessing their dialogue would be very similar? For some reason I'm ok with having three normals.

And then Ankha doesn't really fit the theme of my town even though she's pretty awesome and I already have Willow a Snooty which looks really cute in my town and I really like the sheep animation.

Does anyone have any thoughts on this? I know it's a personal choice of course, but I'd love for someone to weigh the pros and cons or give me their opinion a little to help me figure out what I should do. Much thanks.

 

[Krissi2197]

I feel like Ankha is the weak link here because she doesn't go with the theme of your town. She's a great villager to have, but if you're going for a specific theme, I say sell/give her away or trade her for somebody who would fit your theme!

 

[aimeekitty]

Yeah that's what I'm thinking, too. I think what's tougher for me is choosing who else on top of Ankha to get rid of so that I can have all the personalities.

I guess I could get rid of one of my three normals. I can't get rid of Flurry or Merengue though, I love their shape and everything too much so that leaves Lucy but she was one of my originals and I think she's really cute, too.

I like Shep a lot, but I worry that his dialogue would be too similar to Julian. :\ It seems to me like somehow with the normals its less obvious to me that they are saying the same thing? I dunno. I don't have Julian in my town so I don't know if Shep and him would feel too similar or not.

 

[Yugi Moto]

Well if you're looking for an asian flavor then genji certainly fits that and fits the color scheme you're looking for

Other suggestions are filbert, Egbert and Drago for the lazy personality. If you would like me to elaborate on any of my choices at all I'd be happy to

 

[aimeekitty]

ah well I'm actually trying to decide who to get rid of and who to keep, not who to add.

I had drago but I accidentally boxed him *____*

 

[Yugi Moto]

ah well I'm actually trying to decide who to get rid of and who to keep, not who to add.

I had drago but I accidentally boxed him *____*

Omg I'm an idiot I'm so sry

I misread and thought you were asking for new villagers >.<