Help me choose who to replace

[raqball]

I have a Molly amiibo card and am going to replace one of my peppy villagers. I also am looking for some variety in personalities.

Here is my complete villager list:

Zucker
Marina
Lolly
Lily
Ozzy
Daisy
Kid Cat
Raddle
Twiggy (peppy)
Ruby (peppy)

So Molly is going to replace either Twiggy or Ruby. I honestly like them both but can't deal with 2 of the peppy personalities. I am leaning towards keeping Twiggy and letting Ruby go but I am back and forth..

Thoughts?

 

[Krissi2197]

If it were up to me I'd get rid of Ruby over Twiggy for sure.

I'm not biased or anything bc I also have Twiggy; Ruby just isn't pleasing to the eyes to me.

 

[Kurashiki]

i would go with replacing ruby as well!

 

[raqball]

If it were up to me I'd get rid of Ruby over Twiggy for sure.

I'm not biased or anything bc I also have Twiggy; Ruby just isn't pleasing to the eyes to me.

Agree and that's the main reason I want to keep Twiggy. She is easier on the eyes... Ruby was one of my 1st villagers which might be the only reason I don;t really want to let her go... I am leaning towards letting Ruby go though.

 

[Xara]

i’m gonna throw my two cents in and agree that i would also let ruby go - i much prefer twiggy’s design over ruby’s aha

 

[BubbleBlowinDoubleBaby]

I'm in agreement over keeping Twiggy. I just think I like Twiggy a bit more.

 

[KYMoose]

I know everyone here already gave you the same answer. But, I made a similar choice and replaced Ruby with an Amiibo villager (Skye). I haven't regretted it at all. Ruby is very cute, but I agree with Krissi. Her design is slightly jarring to me for some reason. Plus if she was one of your first villagers, then you are missing out on the themed house anyway.

Enjoy Molly! She's a sweetheart!

 

[raqball]

Thanks for all the replies. I am pretty sure I'll replace Ruby... I'll wait a few days and make sure before doing it but I am pretty positive I am keeping Twiggy...

 

[Sir Takoya]

Twiggy. If you get rid of Ruby, you'll have two birds.
I don't really like Twiggy's eyebrows, but that's just a personal opinion. ><

 

[raqball]

Twiggy. If you get rid of Ruby, you'll have two birds.
I don't really like Twiggy's eyebrows, but that's just a personal opinion. ><

Yeah I have 2 Octopuses as well in Zucker and Marina... I don't mind having 2 of as I also have 2 cats right now. Kid Cat and Lolly... Kid Cat is getting replaced with Sprocket (maybe Ribbot) though. I also have 2 frogs with Lily and Raddle so if I replace Kid Cat with Ribbot instead of Sprocket then I need to boot Raddle for someone else as I don't want 3 frogs.

I don't mind using Ribbot instead of Sprocket but it will be a pain trying to find someone I want. I have a few Amiibo cards but the cards I have are Molly (she is incoming), Sprocket and Ribbot. I don't have any others so I'd need to find a replacement via mystery Islands and that's a dice roll...

My final'ish villager list will be:

Firm - (never Leaving)
-----------------------
Zucker (Octopus)
Marina (Octopus)
Lolly (Cat)
Lily (Frog)
Ozzy (Koala)
Daisy (Dog)
Twiggy (Bird)
Molly (Bird)

Up in the air - (depends who I replace Kid Cat with)
------------------------------------------------------------
Raddle (Frog) (he would be replaced if I take Ribbot instead of Sprocket to replace Kid Cat)
Sprocket (Ostrich) (maybe unless I go with Ribbot instead)

2 Frogs (maybe 3 if I use Ribbot so Raddle would need to go for someone new)
2 Octopuses
2 Birds
1 Koala
1 Dog
1 Cat
1 Ostrich (maybe 0)