I have the same question! The guide says she likes simple things and the color orange. I was thinking about a basketball, since it wouldn’t look too out of place with her fall woods decor, but I’d prefer to only give fruit so as to not impact my villagers’ wardrobe or housing. Can I just wrap a ten stack of oranges? They’re orange!
Not that anyone cares, but she seemed to like the oranges. It was absolutely hilarious to see her and Peanut dancing around nonstop doing the glee reaction for the entire party too
If she likes the color Orange, give her an Orange (assuming it's a foreign fruit). If you're close friends with her already there's a chance she will send you her picture in the mail the following day!