Help Deciding on Villagers ;U;

[shendere]

I'm happy with it, don't get me wrong--but at the same time, I see Snake, Cookie and Stitches and think they're sooo cute, and I'd love to have them. At this time.. I may just be able to do one, or two.
I try to have all personality types so there's also that Chief is my only cranky so I wouldn't wanna remove him, nor Bob, Judy, Sherb, Dom or Pietro. As well as only Uchi.. Which just leaves Tangy.

I love Tangy. She's cute.

I love when they SING. I cannot confirm if cookie, or mostly SNAKE, stitches, if they'll sing at all LOL. But yeah, need help. Would appreciate if you think I should just keep her, also lmk!! ♥♥

 

[senbeiiscool]

I think you can keep Tangy for now until she pings and then let her go to find one of the other villagers on your list that you want? You can keep that your free spot so you can swap in Cookie, Snake and Stitches in that spot and keep the other villagers. Although I do think that keeping villagers for the sake of personality isn't the best reason so you should just go with who you love, even if it means kicking off villagers of a certain type that you only have 1 of. Make sure you get all DIYs and reactions from them first though if you're going down this route!

 

[shendere]

I think you can keep Tangy for now until she pings and then let her go to find one of the other villagers on your list that you want? You can keep that your free spot so you can swap in Cookie, Snake and Stitches in that spot and keep the other villagers. Although I do think that keeping villagers for the sake of personality isn't the best reason so you should just go with who you love, even if it means kicking off villagers of a certain type that you only have 1 of. Make sure you get all DIYs and reactions from them first though if you're going down this route!

Do certain types give you certain reactions or something? :0 I love all the others I have, I love Tangy too, she pinged yesterday but I didn't have her move. I have the amiibo to move those in anytime though! Just wasn't sure who, but I'm probably leaning more towards Snake, I'll see how he looks. Though stitches is so cute. Never had him before but he certainly is very adorable in this one. Cookie would be my first dog villager too!

 

[senbeiiscool]

Do certain types give you certain reactions or something? :0 I love all the others I have, I love Tangy too, she pinged yesterday but I didn't have her move. I have the amiibo to move those in anytime though! Just wasn't sure who, but I'm probably leaning more towards Snake, I'll see how he looks. Though stitches is so cute. Never had him before but he certainly is very adorable in this one. Cookie would be my first dog villager too!

Yes! Reactions are locked by personality! Here's the list:

Normal - Pleased, Fearful, Sadness, Glee, Daydreaming
Peppy - Happiness, Aggravation, Sleepy, Curiosity, Mischief
Snooty - Joy, Intense, Thought, Sighing, Amazed, Love.
Big Sister - Greetings, Laughter, Cold Chill, Apologetic, Disagreement, Confident
Lazy - Delight, Bashfulness, Sorrow, Mistaken, Shyness, Pride.
Jock - Surprise, encouraging, Sneezing, Distress, Shocked, Flourish
Cranky - Agreement, Worry, sheepish-ness, Bewilderment, Inspiration
Smug - Smirking, Resignation, Heartbreak, Dozing, Showmanship.

I believe it's based on friendship level so the ones farthest to the right will be the last ones you will learn.

I think if you have the Tangy amiibo, it'll make the choice even easier since if you don't like any of them you can always have her back! Snake is super cute! I would def go for him!

 

[kojuuro]

Aww man that's such a difficult choice, though i agree if you are keeping villagers for the sake of their personality, I'd get all their diys and reactions first, and then go for the ones you love. Tangy is such a great villager, though it's ok to cycle them out eventually for others you love, even if it's hard ;__;

 

[shendere]

Yes! Reactions are locked by personality! Here's the list:

Normal - Pleased, Fearful, Sadness, Glee, Daydreaming
Peppy - Happiness, Aggravation, Sleepy, Curiosity, Mischief
Snooty - Joy, Intense, Thought, Sighing, Amazed, Love.
Big Sister - Greetings, Laughter, Cold Chill, Apologetic, Disagreement, Confident
Lazy - Delight, Bashfulness, Sorrow, Mistaken, Shyness, Pride.
Jock - Surprise, encouraging, Sneezing, Distress, Shocked, Flourish
Cranky - Agreement, Worry, sheepish-ness, Bewilderment, Inspiration
Smug - Smirking, Resignation, Heartbreak, Dozing, Showmanship.

I believe it's based on friendship level so the ones farthest to the right will be the last ones you will learn.

I think if you have the Tangy amiibo, it'll make the choice even easier since if you don't like any of them you can always have her back! Snake is super cute! I would def go for him!

Thanks so much for all your help and precious info!

Post automatically merged: May 14, 2020

Aww man that's such a difficult choice, though i agree if you are keeping villagers for the sake of their personality, I'd get all their diys and reactions first, and then go for the ones you love. Tangy is such a great villager, though it's ok to cycle them out eventually for others you love, even if it's hard ;__;

She really is?? I wish we had more, it's so hard to let her go but I also would love to have snake and try the others too!

 

[senbeiiscool]

Thanks so much for all your help and precious info! ♥

Post automatically merged: May 14, 2020

She really is?? I wish we had more, it's so hard to let her go but I also would love to have snake and try the others too!

You're welcome! I'm using this list to keep track of what I've learned myself and it's really useful haha happy to share it!