Help decide who to keep?

[Aeryka]

So, I don't really like any peppy villagers but I went with one that would probably be my "Favorite" of the bunch (BonBon) but she doesn't make me excited to talk to her.
Basically I wanted one of each type for the projects and for peppy I wanted the bridge and metal bench.

I adore all my other animals, I have two smug (Zell and Julian) and two Lazies (Lucky and Erik)..

I really want a sheep, two in particular Muffy and Pietro..
I gave Muffy to someone in my cycling thread and it hurt a little because I like her a lot.
Now I have Pietro in my cycling town and I'm not sure If I should take him.

If I got rid of BonBon and got one of those two I'd either have 2 uchis or 3 smugs..

I can possibly get rid of Deirdre and Zell since I have two other deers..but they're cute also ; u; (Which means I take both sheep but still have an okay peppy)

If I waited for BonBon to give me what I want (sounds mean), that means I will have to give Pietro to someone else and then buy him back later. Which shouldn't be too hard.

Any opinions on what I should do?
Hopefully I didn't explain too horribly..

 

[00ToxicLove00]

Replace Deirdre with Muffy

 

[Khaelis]

Replace Deirdre with Muffy

This is what I would also do personally.

Then again I am being somewhat biased because I don't like Dierdre's design.

 

[Aeryka]

This is what I would also do personally.

Then again I am being somewhat biased because I don't like Dierdre's design.

I'll consider this. I only like her design because she's the only female deer that has characteristics similar to deers in real life.

Thinking about having to plot reset muffy in her spot ahhh.. no other open space in that area left ;~;