Help Decide The Future of Mana

[Majora Moon]

I am still working on narrowing down who I want to have on my Island; Mana.


Current Villagers:
Shari (Keeping)
Hans (Keeping)
Marina (Keeping)
Rory (Keeping)
Tiansheng (Keeping)
Audie (Undecided)
Raymond (Booting)
Spike (Booting)
Opal (Booting)
Erik (Booting)

Planing to Move In:
Rolf
Chester

I still need to decide on a Snooty villager. Then I need an extra female. I have a few I am heavily considering and would like some input. Who do you think goes well with my current line up best? Originally I was going to keep Audie. But I am really considering ditching her. I have not decided there, and if she does leave, I will move Whitney in her place.

So should I get Whitney and boot Audie? Or should I keep Audie? I have both cards, so getting them will not be an issue. I am just not interested in having both wolves. I am planning to get Wolf Link when I start up my New Leaf town again, and am really just not in the mood for three total wolves. Or should I not have either Wolf on this island, and get some more unique villagers?

So the question is this. Which ONE of these do you think I should take:

Snooty: Whitney, Gwen, Judy
Peppy: Audie, Tammi, Rilla
Normal (extra female): Bertha, Nana

Again, I DON'T want Audie AND Whitney. So please, which three should I take to round out my island? Should I keep Audie? Should I swap her? Please let me know which three you think will go well with the rest of my line up.

 

[Lilyacre]

From those options, I’d choose Whitney, Tammi and Nana. They all have unique and cute designs in my opinion.

As a side note, I personally wouldn’t worry too much about choosing villagers that ‘go well’ with the rest of your islanders. Just choose the 10 that you like the most and enjoy having them around. You could always keep that last ‘extra female’ slot as an open slot that you keep rotating, just to keep things interesting.