Have you ever been disappointed by a villager?

[carackobama]

I?ve seen quite a few threads and discussions online about villagers that people didn?t like at first but that ended up growing on them, or villagers that pleasantly surprised them, but has anyone ever had a villager that disappointed them? Whether it was a dreamie that didn?t fit into town or that you didn?t like as much as you thought you would, or a villager who seemed cool but you didn?t end up being a fan of - I?m really interested to know your stories!

Personally I haven?t hugely had this happen; the closest thing is that Chrissy moved in a few weeks ago (one of my dreamies) and so far I?m not sure how well she fits. She?s adorable and looks great in my pink town but I?m not ~in love~ with her yet, but I might be because it?s early days and we?re not close friends yet. She also has to compete with Tangy, who?s also peppy and is my favourite villager ever, so the recycled dialogue is a little annoying. I?m hoping that I start to love her more over time though!

 

[Alexis]

i dislike that the snooty villagers always talk about "subtle beauty"
it gets really annoying
i have 4 snooty villagers AND THEY ALL SAY THAT SAME LINE EVERY FREAKING DAY D:<

 

[felixfelicis]

Merengue. I thought she would be a nice addition because she's cute yes, but oh my gosh so boringgggg

honestly I think all normal villagers are boring

 

[Alexis]

Merengue. I thought she would be a nice addition because she's cute yes, but oh my gosh so boringgggg

honestly I think all normal villagers are boring

i was originally going to make her one of my dreamies, now im glad i didnt haha - i cant stand unlikeable personalities D:<

 

[drowningfairies]

Probably Julian or Ankha.

I'm not sure what it was, but they didn't interest me at all.
Despite being really interesting looking, and loved by many, I couldn't vibe with them.

 

[lucylives]

Julian, honestly i thought i would love her </3

I don't know what it is about her, i guess she just wasn't what i was expecting?

 

[Khaelis]

Rudy. I thought he looked neat at first, and after a while I started to realize he was... pretty bland for a cat villager.

 

[Valzed]

Shep. I love dogs & thought he would be great to have in my town but he just drove me crazy. It's not Lazy villagers in general because I've had others and loved them. It was Shep himself. I have no clue why either.

Oh, and Epona also. I have always loved Epona in any LoZ game she was in but Epona as a Peppy villager just didn't mesh in my head. To me Epona would have made a great Uchi type.

 

[red_odessa]

Goldie! SO cute, was a firm favourite in pocket camp, but actually turns out to be a pretty bland character in ACNL. I prefer Lucky nowadays - like Goldie but less basic

 

[Stephanie92]

Julian, I never really liked him when he was in my town, I just never got him

 

[floatingzoo]

Shep, just a little bit. I have been wanting him for a really long time and just got him in my second town. His design is really cute but I never realized he was a smug villager and I don't think it matches him.

 

[Valzed]

Shep, just a little bit. I have been wanting him for a really long time and just got him in my second town. His design is really cute but I never realized he was a smug villager and I don't think it matches him.

Good grief - I forgot Shep was smug. For some reason I thought he was Lazy. I still don't know why he drove me nuts because one of my favorite villagers is Smug.

 

[Kirbyz]

Honestly, I'd probably say Fauna, Rosie, and Goldie. They're pretty boring and I hear the same thing EVERYDAY. They literally all say the same thing and everyone hypes them up, but they're just not interesting. Going to end up moving them out of my town anyway.

 

[Stevey Queen]

Julian, honestly i thought i would love her </3

I don't know what it is about her, i guess she just wasn't what i was expecting?

Julian's a boy so maybe that's why lol

In city folk, I had Pierce in my town and he was all right. Pretty cool eagle villager. One day he asked me to give him furniture and I spent like 2000 on a modern sofa or something like that. And bells aren't as easily obtained in city Folk like they are in New Leaf. So when he rewards me with a cardboard box, I flip.

I reported him to Pelly for being rude and wearing inappropriate clothes and next time I see him he's just wearing a plain white shirt, which kinda makes him look he's wearing nothing at all.

Hated him ever since.

 

[LadyDestani]

I was kind of disappointed with Pashmina. She was one of the first villagers to move into my town after I started it. I loved her name, her look, and her house, but I just didn't click with her. It might have been the fact that she was the first Uchi villager I ever interacted with. Maybe it just took me some time for their personality to grow on me. I don't know. I just didn't like her as much as I thought I would. I let her move out and I've liked every Uchi villager I've had since then to varying degrees. I'd probably be willing to give her another chance, but I don't think I'd ever love her.

I was also kind of disappointed by Julian. When I heard there was a unicorn villager, I immediately looked him up because I've always loved unicorns. His appearance is just sort of okay to me, nothing special. I do love his house interior, but I feel like he could be better. I'm sorry, I know a lot of people love him and that's great, but I just don't feel the same way.

 

[maple22]

I've had Rosie in two different games. I understand why she's incredibly popular (been in all the games + the movie, has a pretty cute design), but I've never really cared for her.

 

[Snowesque]

Not really a looks/personality thing; but I personally get a little urked whenever a villager gets sad I did not take on their task; more so when I really need to talk to them.

 

[moonbyu]

Julian.

I remember people fawning over him since he was a unicorn so I brought him from someone online. My expectations were way too high atm. I thought he would be more cooler just because he's a unicorn. Unfortunately, I was very let down. I managed to sell him for almost 5mil IGB. I will never understand why people like him so much.

 

[Sweetley]

I would say Julian. While I do understand why he is may popular doing to the fact that he
is a unique villager ("unicorn"), I didn't found him that special when I had him in my town
for a while. I mean, sure, at first, it was kinda cool to have him, but after a while, he
became kinda boring? Or at least he wasn't that much special anymore then all the other
villagers around him. I don't hate him now or anything, he's ok, but yeah... Not much better
then all the other villagers out there in my opinion.

 

[2kimi2furious]

I was disappointed by Coco. There didn't seem to be anything special about her apart from her looks.I remember letting her move out the first chance I got because she was boring.