I had both in my town (Skye was one of my original 10 and Freya moved in via campsite) I LOVE Skye! She's become one of my top three villagers along with Kiki and Ribbot both of whom had been my favorites since GC so that's not an easy feat! I never really clicked with Freya, so I let someone who had her as a dreamie have her. So my answer is definitely my bb Skye
I prefer Skye. I love her.. Her colors and design are just cuter to me. I have seen both in game and I think Skye looks nicer. I think it's the eye makeup that kills Freya for me...