
I've never had either but every time I see Poppy while visiting dream addresses, I just feel so happy, she's adorable.
I'd say Flurry. Only because I had Poppy at one point in time and I didn't really like her. She just felt really plain and ordinary and really nothing special. Although I prefer the squirrels villager model wise, I think having Flurry in town would be absolutely adorable since she's so small and cute. Also I think her little blue eyebrows make her look a little more unique and less ordinary compared to Poppy. With her, her house was really really ordinary.