First villager that comes to mind

[samsquared]

Dora!

Villager who probably puts the most thought into their letters

 

[Seastar]

Kiki

Villager who loves rain.

 

[necrofantasia]

lily

villager who was popular in high school

 

[Ace Marvel]

Whitney

Villager most likely to be a real housewife of Animal Crossing

 

[necrofantasia]

tiffany

villager most likely to have a criminal record

 

[Lightmare]

bella

villager who's famous on tiktok

 

[petaI]

raymond

villager who would be good at cooking

 

[cagycorvidae]

aurora

villager who seems suspicious but is actually trustworthy

 

[cloudmask]

renee

villager who goes to bed late and doesn't wake up til afternoon

 

[Shampsto]

Fuchsia

A villager who's a big sweet-tooth

 

[Ace Marvel]

Merengue

A villager that would fight over the last pizza slice?

 

[Rosie Moon]

Frita... but would that technically be cannibalism?

Villager most likely to be a social media addict?

 

[Clock]

Jacques
A villager that uses too much Snapchat

 

[Mr_Persona]

Freya

A villager who is a gamer

 

[ForgottenT]

Derwin

An annoying villager

 

[Hanif1807]

Barold

Smartest Villager

 

[spawnpoint]

Doc

Dumbest villager

 

[Hedgehugs]

Doc

Most likely to accidentally sell their house?

 

[spawnpoint]

Doc

Most likely to accidentally sell their house?

how can he be both the dumbest and smartest?
Anyway, Marshal lol

Villager most likely to be a spy?

 

[Ace Marvel]

Agent S

Villager most likely to run for president?