Probably the spooky lantern since it's such a classic Halloween item and the different faces are adorable, plus if you turn it around it's a great decoration too. I have a bunch in my forest and it helps fill the empty space and make the forest look more alive. But my second favorite is definitely the fence - it's really cute and very versatile! So far I've used it to surround since trees and around the area I've reserved for the Roost. It complements the iron and stone fence really well, and the pumpkin and heart shapes that it makes are so cute.
But otherwise I'd say all of them are pretty useful this time of year, with the exception of the table since it's too bulky and I'm not a fan of the face in the center.
I love the lantern set! It looks so good in my pumpkin patch which I’ll be keeping year round. I like how you can turn the pumpkin items backwards and they just look like regular pumpkins
I love the spooky tower because I love to decorate around my villagers' houses. I feel like the island is too empty if I cram all their houses together, so I spaced them way out so that they have a little fenced-in yard for items related to their personality and hobby. So any little decorations that are seasonal that I can add to their yards to make them feel cozy and cute and more alive are my favorites. I have a little spooky lantern or spooky tower in all my villagers' yards now.
I really love a lot of the furniture! I picked chair / table because, even though the table has a face, it’s still very cute and natural looking. Same with the chair—it looks like just a sliced pumpkin (although I’m sad we can’t put items on top of it... lol.)
My other choice would’ve been the carriage, but I don’t have anywhere to put it right now, so it’s just in my storage collecting dust. >u<