Phish Food!
They have a lot of great flavors, especially at the actual shop VS what you get in the containers. I love the Coffee Toffee Crunch and their sorbets as well.
I have a sort of mixed up relationship with Ben & Jerry's right now just because I'm going vegan and I'm supposed to avoid gluten (I don't have celiac's but my skin feels weird after I eat more than a small amount of gluten), but: when I wasn't vegan and had their dairy ice creams, Peanut Butter Bites, and when I can tolerate a bit of gluten and will have a non-dairy dessert, probably Coffee Caramel Fudge.