I got Dom and Flo as my starters and while Flo already moved out a while ago, Dom's still on my island. I'm not sure if I'm gonna keep him or not, I mean I like him, but he's not one of my dreamies and I already have two sheep villagers (Pietro and Eunice). So far, he didn't ask me about to leave, so I guess I will decide spontaneous whenever I will let him stay or not once he will come up with the important question.
My starters were Lyman and Tammy. Both good villagers, nice to have around, but I just can't deal with their sad empty homes. Tammy has moved to someone else's island who is really happy with her, and I think I will have to move Lyman out and back in at some point. I like Lyman too much to just ditch him forever