I have Papi and Victoria, used to have Colton(come back PLEASE) so YEAH I LOVE the horses SOOOOOOO MUCH*-* Roscoe is also awesome!! I love them all!! Elmer and Savannah are amazing too!!
Hmm, I've only had Julian, Colton, and Savannah. I didn't really care for Savannah, I loved Colton at first but got used to him (maybe because he had the worst spot ever -_- so it affects it and I'm being biased), and I'm planning to move Julian out soon since he's not really a dreamy of mine and am trying to make a space for one.
Overall, I don't not like them, but they're also not someone I want or one of my dreamies.
I LOOOVE the horse villagers! Victoria is my fave, I have great memories of her in WW so was so glad I adopted her in NL too such an underrated villager!
I love Julian too and have him in my second town. Maybe he is over hyped but he's still pretty in my opinion, don't care what anyone says!
I wouldn't go out of my way to get any of them, but weirdly I kind of like them. I don't particularly like horses in real life and there are none of them horse villagers that are especially appealing. So that's weird to me.
I was going to say "no" because it seems like the only horse I ever see is Ed and he just looks sickly to me.
But then I took a look at all the horses in the New Leaf Wiki and I actually really like the look of most of them. I currently have Papi in my town him and I adore him. Okapis are one of my favorite animals.