Daisy or Cookie? Villager advice

[hellokitty]

Hi! I'm working on my dream town and am putting together my favorite villagers
so far I have

zucker
inkwell
olivia
whitney
skye
pekoe
drago
diana
daisy
tangy

I desperately wanna move out inkwell for Ruby! but right now I'm deciding between Daisy and Cookie. which fits the pastel aesthetic more? and who should I move pekoe out for? If anyone wants Pekoe (or Daisy if I choose cookie) lmk BTW.

 

[meggtheegg]

Oooo DAISY DAISY DAISY

I think she's so underrated and I wish I could have her in my town! And she's pastel yellow and blue! She's super cute. I think they both fit the pastel aesthetic, since cookie is a light pink. But I just think Daisy is more cute, her colors are so soft

Also Ruby is a doll I love her, def a good choice

And some suggestions for pekoe: Blanche, Merry, baabara

 

[hellokitty]

I had merry but she moved out unfortunately. but Ooooohh!!! Blanche is so pretty!! I'll think about that omg!

 

[meggtheegg]

I had merry but she moved out unfortunately. but Ooooohh!!! Blanche is so pretty!! I'll think about that omg!

Blanche is a gorgeous villager! I used to have her in my town as well, and she's great!

 

[Moonfish]

Cookie would be my choice. I legit had to search the wiki for Daisy because I couldn’t remember who that was lol. Also, Blanche is fantastic. Definitely an underrated snooty.

 

[Dorian]

I would absolutely go for Daisy! She is my favorite sweetie and is so beautiful. But really, it depends on whether you want a peppy or sweetie. Regardless of who you choose, both are wonderful.

 

[vvindows98]

i vote Daisy!! she's one of the most underrated villagers imo, i had her in my old town and loved her <3

 

[Lenndrix]

What about keeping Daisy and moving Pekoe out for Cookie?

Although I will say that I love Blanche. She's adorable and underrated imo...

 

[Mayor Kera]

Cookie. c:

 

[Topaz13]

Cookie!

She’s actually my all-time favorite so I may not be the one to suggest one way or the other

 

[ILikeFroakies]

Cookie just. Probably because I like the name better. Appearance wise it's too hard to decide

 

[TamaMushroom]

Daisy seems to fit it better in my opinion. Though the inside of cookies house may have more of a pastel adjacent theme going on than Daisy's. Daisy's house is like a library/museum feel, definitely historic, where as Cookie's room has the patchwork furniture, which offers more color for sure. The exteriors of both would match just fine to be honest!

 

[Athelwyn]

I think either would fit your pastel aesthetic, so the difference is: Do you want a cartoon dog (Cookie) or one who looks like a real puppy (Daisy)?

 

[Alsafie]

I?ve had both Cookie and Daisy and I?ve got to say I?d choose Daisy! I agree that she is very underrated, but she is very sweet

 

[Mr_Persona]

Daisy!

 

[daisyflowers]

daisy

just because that?s my name

 

[Flare]

I'd choose Cookie. She's really cool and nice lmao. I like her house a ton too.

Daisy is pretty good too but overall I'd go with Cookie.

 

[tiffanistarr]

Daisy and Cookie both are beyond adorable and Daisy really underappreciated, but on this one I'm going to have to go with Cookie. Diana and Whitney are both white so adding Cookie might add just the right pop of color!