I'm between Lily and Tia. I used to have Lily in Wild World and in my main town and adored her, but due to a silly time-traveling accident I lost her Now I have Tia and she's super cute! Marina is also really adorable and cool
Marina with no doubt. When she moved into my town in Wild World I instantly fell in love with her and since then she has been in all my towns in Wild World, Let's Go to the city (aka City Folk) and New Leaf. The day I lost her in New Leaf has been one of the hardest days in all my Animal Crossing years.