Cranston, Colton, or Kidd?

[Buttonsy]

Which villager should I let go of? I currently have Cranston and Colton, and I love both of them a lot, but I've wanted Kidd for a very long time, not only that but goats are my favourite animal and I only have one goat in any of my towns.

I'm kinda thinking of swapping one of them for Kidd, but I'm not sure what to do. BTW, personality doesn't matter because I have a lazy so I'll either end up with two lazies and a smug, or two smugs and a lazy, either of which is fine to me.

 

[MayorJudyOfZootopia]

Cranston, i personally loved kidd when he was in my town

 

[GirlPolarBear]

I personally prefer Cranston but maybe because I'm a huge fan of Swimmingbird941's lets plays of ACNL heh

 

[Kurashiki]

personally i'm not a fan of the goats, so i would keep them!

 

[Amherst]

Is Cranston really that good? I have him and I'm dying to get rid of him. But maybe I should give him a chance?

 

[vel]

kidd is more special, i feel like he adds variety. cranston won't freaking leave it's so annoying.

 

[Buttonsy]

Is Cranston really that good? I have him and I'm dying to get rid of him. But maybe I should give him a chance?

Idk, with 333 villagers, everyone is gonna have different preferences, I personally find Cranston to just be kinda weird in an endearing way.

 

[ChillyKio]

I'd let go of Colton... he's not my favorite, but of course, opinions differ. I think it'd be good to have Kidd in your town since you like goats so much, and I prefer Cranston over Colton.

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

Cranston. Colton is wonderful and I would love him in my town one day. I don't really like Cranstons design for some reason...and I think having Kidd and Colton would be so cute since they're both smugs. I love having 2 smugs in my town. Kids is adorable and I couldn't believe when I've seen he's a tier 5. Swap out Cranston for Kidd would be my vote

 

[supercataleena]

Dont worry you will forget about Cranston in a week. Definitely go for Kidd.

 

[GuerreraD]

I totally solidarize with you about wanting Kidd! Believe me, I looked for him everywhere for a long time (weeks) until I finally got him!
I also had Colton in my town back in the day and he was great, I liked him a lot, so... I suggest you let go of Cranston because actually I don't remember who is, but having both Kidd and Colton sounds just too good to not do it, specially if you like them both!

 

[Eline]

I'd get rid of Colton. I think the ostrichs and goats are super cute and I'm not very fond of the horses anyway.

 

[Pookie4557]

I would let go of Colton personally, but I really love Cranston soo.

 

[axo]

Cranston!

 

[namiieco]

I'd keep both since I don't like Kidd or swap Colton with Kidd because I kinda like Cranston, though I've never had him.