Could Brawl get the highest ratings ever?

[Jeremy]

No, every major release gets speculation like this.

Also, who decides what constitutes "the highest ratings?"

www.metacritic.com
www.gamerankings.com

Why do they get to decide that?

They don't, it's an opinion thing in all reality, ratings mean nothing.

They don't....

They find as many reviews as possible and average them

 

[SL92]

[quote="Shadow_] Don't fix it if it ain't broke.

That could be said about Mario Party. [/quote]
Mario Party is on its 10th installment, or something. I lost track.

Smash Bros has three games. Most franchises haven't even perfected a formula by their third installment.

 

[Bulerias]

No, every major release gets speculation like this.

Also, who decides what constitutes "the highest ratings?"

www.metacritic.com
www.gamerankings.com

Why do they get to decide that?

They don't, it's an opinion thing in all reality, ratings mean nothing.

Did you even pay attention? Go to those sites again. They're a reviewing aggregate. They compile review scores.

If you're gonna say "review scores don't matter because they're opinion!11!", that's irrelevant. We're discussing "highest ratings ever", which essentially means best review scores all around.

 

[Kyle]

No, every major release gets speculation like this.

Also, who decides what constitutes "the highest ratings?"

www.metacritic.com
www.gamerankings.com

Why do they get to decide that?

They don't, it's an opinion thing in all reality, ratings mean nothing.

Did you even pay attention? Go to those sites again. They're a reviewing aggregate. They compile review scores.

If you're gonna say "review scores don't matter because they're opinion!11!", that's irrelevant. We're discussing "highest ratings ever", which essentially means best review scores all around.

It being a opinion is relevent.

"This Pokemon game is fantastic, it gets a 9.2 out of 10!"

"I don't like Pokemon, but LOLOLOZ ok sure I'll buy it."




:huh:

Anyway, your discussing reviews/opinions of the greatest games? OK, its not revolutionary like OoT but it'll do ok. (I think I already said that?)

It remains alot like Melee, but it will probably be the best Wifi game yet which ups it. Plus loads of content. Not best rating ever worthy though.

 

[Jeremy]

No, every major release gets speculation like this.

Also, who decides what constitutes "the highest ratings?"

www.metacritic.com
www.gamerankings.com

Why do they get to decide that?

They don't, it's an opinion thing in all reality, ratings mean nothing.

Did you even pay attention? Go to those sites again. They're a reviewing aggregate. They compile review scores.

If you're gonna say "review scores don't matter because they're opinion!11!", that's irrelevant. We're discussing "highest ratings ever", which essentially means best review scores all around.

It being a opinion is relevent.

"This Pokemon game is fantastic, it gets a 9.2 out of 10!"

"I don't like Pokemon, but LOLOLOZ ok sure I'll buy it."




:huh:

Anyway, your discussing reviews/opinions of the greatest games? OK, its not revolutionary like OoT but it'll do ok. (I think I already said that?)

It remains alot like Melee, but it will probably be the best Wifi game yet which ups it. Plus loads of content. Not best rating ever worthy though.

You've played it?

 

[Kyle]

No, every major release gets speculation like this.

Also, who decides what constitutes "the highest ratings?"

www.metacritic.com
www.gamerankings.com

Why do they get to decide that?

They don't, it's an opinion thing in all reality, ratings mean nothing.

Did you even pay attention? Go to those sites again. They're a reviewing aggregate. They compile review scores.

If you're gonna say "review scores don't matter because they're opinion!11!", that's irrelevant. We're discussing "highest ratings ever", which essentially means best review scores all around.

It being a opinion is relevent.

"This Pokemon game is fantastic, it gets a 9.2 out of 10!"

"I don't like Pokemon, but LOLOLOZ ok sure I'll buy it."




:huh:

Anyway, your discussing reviews/opinions of the greatest games? OK, its not revolutionary like OoT but it'll do ok. (I think I already said that?)

It remains alot like Melee, but it will probably be the best Wifi game yet which ups it. Plus loads of content. Not best rating ever worthy though.

You've played it?

Yes.

 

[Jeremy]

Where

 

[Bulerias]

No, every major release gets speculation like this.

Also, who decides what constitutes "the highest ratings?"

www.metacritic.com
www.gamerankings.com

Why do they get to decide that?

They don't, it's an opinion thing in all reality, ratings mean nothing.

Did you even pay attention? Go to those sites again. They're a reviewing aggregate. They compile review scores.

If you're gonna say "review scores don't matter because they're opinion!11!", that's irrelevant. We're discussing "highest ratings ever", which essentially means best review scores all around.

It being a opinion is relevent.

"This Pokemon game is fantastic, it gets a 9.2 out of 10!"

"I don't like Pokemon, but LOLOLOZ ok sure I'll buy it."




:huh:

Anyway, your discussing reviews/opinions of the greatest games? OK, its not revolutionary like OoT but it'll do ok. (I think I already said that?)

It remains alot like Melee, but it will probably be the best Wifi game yet which ups it. Plus loads of content. Not best rating ever worthy though.

...DID YOU READ MY POST?!

Gamerankings is a REVIEW AGGREGATE. Do you honestly think any reviewer writing for a big website is going to spout nonsense like that?

 

[Kyle]

Where

There

 

[Kyle]

No, every major release gets speculation like this.

Also, who decides what constitutes "the highest ratings?"

www.metacritic.com
www.gamerankings.com

Why do they get to decide that?

They don't, it's an opinion thing in all reality, ratings mean nothing.

Did you even pay attention? Go to those sites again. They're a reviewing aggregate. They compile review scores.

If you're gonna say "review scores don't matter because they're opinion!11!", that's irrelevant. We're discussing "highest ratings ever", which essentially means best review scores all around.

It being a opinion is relevent.

"This Pokemon game is fantastic, it gets a 9.2 out of 10!"

"I don't like Pokemon, but LOLOLOZ ok sure I'll buy it."




:huh:

Anyway, your discussing reviews/opinions of the greatest games? OK, its not revolutionary like OoT but it'll do ok. (I think I already said that?)

It remains alot like Melee, but it will probably be the best Wifi game yet which ups it. Plus loads of content. Not best rating ever worthy though.

...DID YOU READ MY POST?!

Lol Bidoof is my fave Pokemon

>.<

 

[Jeremy]

Where

There

So you lied?

:gyroidmad:

 

[ULT.DARKSAMUS]

Brawl is going to be simply amazing. I'm picking up a Wii for it.

 

[DSCUBER9000]

IGN's Matt Casamassina, Mark Bozon, Peer Schneider, AND Fran Mirabella all unanimously agreed that Smash Bros. Brawl is NOT a better game than Suepr Mario Galaxy or Metroid Prime 3.

I do not think this will get the highest ratings ever.

 

[SL92]

I'm not speculating anything, but I have to say that you can't get 11/10, so Brawl cannot get the best scores ever. In my book it'll be Top 5.

 

[Micah]

IGN's Matt Casamassina, Mark Bozon, Peer Schneider, AND Fran Mirabella all unanimously agreed that Smash Bros. Brawl is NOT a better game than Suepr Mario Galaxy or Metroid Prime 3.

I do not think this will get the highest ratings ever.

Galaxy wasn't all it was cracked up to be.

 

[TwilightKing]

IGN's Matt Casamassina, Mark Bozon, Peer Schneider, AND Fran Mirabella all unanimously agreed that Smash Bros. Brawl is NOT a better game than Suepr Mario Galaxy or Metroid Prime 3.

I do not think this will get the highest ratings ever.

You can't spell Ignorant withough IGN.

Don't judge a game based on one websites review. Take a look around before you judge it.

 

[SL92]

IGN's Matt Casamassina, Mark Bozon, Peer Schneider, AND Fran Mirabella all unanimously agreed that Smash Bros. Brawl is NOT a better game than Suepr Mario Galaxy or Metroid Prime 3.

I do not think this will get the highest ratings ever.

Galaxy wasn't all it was cracked up to be.

I think you're totally insane to an infinite degree for saying that, and yeaaaaah...
From a critical standpoint, your view upsets me, to say the least.

I hate it how people suddenly start bashing masterpieces for no reason. And for the record, I think Brawl will be better than both Galaxy and Corruption, although they are extraordinary games.

 

[Tyler]

IGN's Matt Casamassina, Mark Bozon, Peer Schneider, AND Fran Mirabella all unanimously agreed that Smash Bros. Brawl is NOT a better game than Suepr Mario Galaxy or Metroid Prime 3.

I do not think this will get the highest ratings ever.

You can't spell Ignorant withough IGN.

Don't judge a game based on one websites review. Take a look around before you judge it.

Every site is entitled to it's opinion.

But I do agree, only use reviews to start your opinion. If you're really worried (which in the case of brawl, you shouldn't be) rent the game.

 

[TwilightKing]

IGN's Matt Casamassina, Mark Bozon, Peer Schneider, AND Fran Mirabella all unanimously agreed that Smash Bros. Brawl is NOT a better game than Suepr Mario Galaxy or Metroid Prime 3.

I do not think this will get the highest ratings ever.

You can't spell Ignorant withough IGN.

Don't judge a game based on one websites review. Take a look around before you judge it.

Every site is entitled to it's opinion.

But I do agree, only use reviews to start your opinion. If you're really worried (which in the case of brawl, you shouldn't be) rent the game.

Ahaha, oh I know, I just wanted to use that quote




But on the other hand, you can't simply look at a review from one site. You have to look around for multiple opinions before coming up with your own.

 

[Propaganda Man]

Brawl is not only a fantastic game but a huge milestone for Nintendo.