Could Brawl get the highest ratings ever?

[Jeremy]

So far the three things that have reviewed it ('have only seen 3 so far) gave it perfect a score

 

[Micah]

I believe it can, because behind Twilight Princess it's the most anticipated game in a long time. If you can look past some tiny flaws like all games have, it should become a classic.

 

[Propaganda Man]

That's not really significant at all. Sales is what matters.

 

[Jeremy]

That's not really significant at all. Sales is what matters.

Well it sold half a mil in the first day it came out in Japan

 

[Propaganda Man]

That's not really significant at all. Sales is what matters.

Well it sold half a mil in the first day it came out in Japan

It is impressive but it isn't surprising. The American sales is what will tell the story.

 

[Bulerias]

That's not really significant at all. Sales is what matters.

Well it sold half a mil in the first day it came out in Japan

It is impressive but it isn't surprising. The American sales is what will tell the story.

American sales should be a million in the first day. Galaxy sold 500K, first day US, I believe... compared to 250,00 or something in Japan.

It won't get the highest ratings ever, I don't think, but it will definitely be Wii's best game.

 

[Kyle]

No. Much of the gameplay is the same so it'll be a good game, but not like a legend.

Although ratings hardly matter compared to sales.

 

[Micah]

No. Much of the gameplay is the same so it'll be a good game, but not like a legend.

Although ratings hardly matter compared to sales.

I guess it'll feel new to me, because I never owned Melee.

 

[SL92]

Brawl to me looks now like it will outsell anything on the Wii, and be a perfect game to boot. Just listening to the music is a jaw-dropping experience.

No. Much of the gameplay is the same so it'll be a good game, but not like a legend.

Don't fix it if it ain't broke.

I guess it'll feel new to me, because I never owned Melee.

Never too late to get it, I bought my copy two months ago.

 

[Jeremy]

No. Much of the gameplay is the same so it'll be a good game, but not like a legend.

Although ratings hardly matter compared to sales.

But this thread is about ratings, not sales

 

[Trent the Paladin]

It's mainly the game that makes the ratings, so, yeah it'll most likely have the highest rankings until SSB4 comes out.

 

[ƒish]

[quote="Shadow_]

No. Much of the gameplay is the same so it'll be a good game, but not like a legend.

Don't fix it if it ain't broke. [/quote]
That's what they said about Halo.....

I guess the problem was it was broken to begin with. Brawl will be good, but I don't think it'll be my favorite.

 

[Jeremy]

[quote author="

 

[Mino]

No, every major release gets speculation like this.

Also, who decides what constitutes "the highest ratings?"

 

[Bulerias]

No, every major release gets speculation like this.

Also, who decides what constitutes "the highest ratings?"

www.metacritic.com
www.gamerankings.com

 

[Trent the Paladin]

No, every major release gets speculation like this.

Also, who decides what constitutes "the highest ratings?"

www.metacritic.com
www.gamerankings.com

And a band of gamers who love the game to death.

 

[ƒish]

[quote author="

 

[Micah]

[quote="Shadow_] Don't fix it if it ain't broke. [/quote]
That could be said about Mario Party.

 

[Kyle]

Thing about ratings is that its a opinion. :/

 

[Mino]

No, every major release gets speculation like this.

Also, who decides what constitutes "the highest ratings?"

www.metacritic.com
www.gamerankings.com

Why do they get to decide that?

They don't, it's an opinion thing in all reality, ratings mean nothing.