I haven't had it suggested yet, but I don't think I'd build it because it can't be demolished and I already regret my campsite placement. Other than that, I don't like the look of either version, actually.
at first i was thinking of going with the modern one because of copper, but went with classic since i liked its atmosphere more. eventually ended up loving booker, so it was win-win!
I voted for classic because it's the one my town has, but use whatever fits the theme of your town. (Or if you don't have a theme, choose the one you like best)
I got the classic one because Booker is really cute.
But I don't really love either one. I wish the classic one was more polished and the modern one less metal looking, but I guess that's the point of the modern theme.