Cherry or Muffy?

[DarkFox7]

Hey everyone, I have obtained 9/10 of my dreamies and I am having the HARDEST time choosing what I want for my Uchi. I am stuck between two cute villagers: Muffy and Cherry. I wanted Flo first, but didn't like her as much as I thought I would and made her move. Then I wanted Cherry because of how awesome she looks, and now I like Cherry and Muffy pretty much the same. The pros and cons of each villager are:

CHERRY
Pros
- A dog, my second favorite species of the whole game.
- I love her gothic style.
- I love her cute little smirk!

Cons
- I hate her pink color. She has a cute face and everything but yuck, I hate pink.
- I already have a dog in my town that I'm keeping and I like diversity.

MUFFY
Pros
- Really love her gothic style, she's more dark and not bright pink like Cherry.
- I LOVE her house.
- I don't have a sheep in my town so she'd make more diversity.

Cons
- She's a sheep. I've never really liked barnyard animals, not even in real life... They're just... Bleh.
- Her face is kinda weird... I like Cherry's facial expression better.

So, in your opinion, who should I choose? I'm really stuck!

 

[Nzerozoro]

I would get Muffy because I agree with you that Cherry looks weird being pink!

 

[Zeo]

I'd pick Cherry because I have her in my town, and she's really nice.

Also... Cherry's color is pink? Her color looked too red to be pink for me, lol.

 

[debinoresu]

imo cherry's smirk is a little weird but at least its not as weird as miras, miras damn mouth is on her cheek sideways I s2g

I thought I'd mention that cherry isnt pink though, she's red? thats why her name is cherry.

if you want more diversity and hate "pink," though, then go for muffy.

 

[Blockmayus]

I would probably pick Muffy, for the sake of diversity and because Ive had her on an old town and she is really cool! (And the way in which shirts become scarves makes for some really interesting things with her outfit). Also, sheep in this game look really REALLY fluffy and nice (Pictures dont really make them justice, you gotta see them live).

 

[clovetic]

Muffy for sure! Plus the sheep are so cute when they walk, especially when they do that happy dance after talking to another villager.

Haha but yeah, Muffy.

 

[Feloreena]

I'd pick Muffy, but I guess I am little biased as she's my favourite uchi. I would recommend seeing them in dream villages though, it can really help with your decision.

 

[DarkFox7]

I'd pick Muffy, but I guess I am little biased as she's my favourite uchi. I would recommend seeing them in dream villages though, it can really help with your decision.

You know, that's a really good idea. If anyone knows a dream town with Cherry and Muffy please let me know

 

[itzafennecfox]

Cherry. I think Muffy's eyes make her face look weird.

 

[aimeekitty]

have you "met" sheep in the game before? I think they are really cute.

Cherry's bright pink color I find not appealing.
I agree that Muffy's face is a little weird, but I think you would get used to her.

Visit them in some dream towns to see how you like them more.

Try one, if you don't like, try the other.

 

[Sharmista]

I personally would pick Muffy. I love sheep in AC, they are so fluffy and she has this little headdress which I think looks cute. The only thing I'm not to fond of are her eyes, but in my opinion she looks a lot better than Cherry. I just don't like Cherry's color that much or this side mouth she has.

 

[oath2order]

When she's in town, Cherry isn't really pink. It's definitely more of a red.

I honestly suggest getting Cherry. She's adorable.