Chelsea vs Fauna

[Rex of Elysium]

Title says it all. I have both amiibo cards, and want a Normal Deer on my island. Problem is I am not sure which to move in. So which do you think would be the better one that fits the rest of the line up?

I have:
Hans
Rory
Hopper
Chester
Octavian
Cherry
Ankha
Skye
Rilla


Who do you think would be better to have?

One one hand I have Fauna on the island right now. And I know I like her, plus her house, imo, is better. But then you have Chelsea. Having her would be yet another villager who's primary color is white. However, I think having a second Sanrio villager would be nice too, and I want to get to know her.

 

[Moritz]

I say give Chelsea a try and if it doesn't work out, bring back fauna.
no harm done apart from friendship lost but thats fun to earn back

 

[Halloqueen]

While I'm not personally a fan of Chelsea and would usually vouch for Fauna, since you have both amiibo cards and because you're interested in getting to know Chelsea, I'd scan her in and see how you like her. If nothing else, you'll sate your curiosity. If such a time comes that you decide you'd rather have Fauna back, just scan her in again.

 

[Rosch]

You seem to have a colorful cast of villagers. Go with Chelsea.