Can't Decide on Which Villagers I Want?

[MonoSpectator]

So, I'm hopefully going to try trading off some villagers, but I'm not 100% sure on who I want to move in yet as my ideal villagers! Perhaps you fellow AC:NL players can give me some help with this, possibly with past experiences or something of the like?

Here's the current list of Villagers I'm trying to choose from.

Cranky

Kabuki / Tom / Fang

Lazy

Beau / Lucky / Bob / Clay / Punchy / Stitches

Jock

Genji / Cousteau / Snake / Ribbot / Rory

Smug

Eugene / Marshal / Klaus

Snooty

Ankha / Blanche / Soleil / Yuka

Normal

Alice / Chevre / Flurry / Gladys / Skye

Peppy

Flora / Rosie / Wendy / Tangy

Uchi

Pashmina / Phoebe
​

I only have a some that I definitely want in my town. That's Lucky, Beau, and Chevre, so that leaves 7 open spots. I already have Pashmina in my town, but I'm wondering if I trade out for Phoebe...I'm not sure yet though. I want to at least have one from each personality type as well.

What do you all think?

 

[Mary]

Fang, Beau, Lucky, Genji, Ankha, Chevre, Rosie, Phoebe, Flora, Flurry. That's what I'd do.

 

[MonoSpectator]

Fang, Beau, Lucky, Genji, Ankha, Chevre, Rosie, Phoebe, Flora, Flurry. That's what I'd do.

Oooh I actually like that set up :3 It's only missing a Smug villager, although I think I'm leaning towards Marshal for that one.
Maybe Fang, Beau, Lucky, Genji, Marshal, Ankha, Chevre, Rosie, Phoebe, and Flurry... I'm iffy on Flurry at the moment. She's super cute and is currently in my town...but I'm not 100% on her. However, It's nice to have a hamster like her ^_^.

 

[juneau]

I would go with:
Fang
Beau
Ribbot
Marshal
Ankha
Chevre
Rosie
Pashmina

 

[Mary]

Oops, meant to put Eugene instead of Flurry.

 

[harvington]

get Bob!!! He's great, and he sends really funny letters if you write to him a lot and become his friend.

 

[MonoSpectator]

I would go with:
Fang
Beau
Ribbot
Marshal
Ankha
Chevre
Rosie
Pashmina

XD looks like there's a general leaning towards Fang, Ankha, and Rosie :3 I like those three a lot as well :3

- - - Post Merge - - -

get Bob!!! He's great, and he sends really funny letters if you write to him a lot and become his friend.

Hehe, judging by the pictures I see of him, he seems like a pretty cool cat (no pun intended.) ^^

 

[juneau]

Haha, Fang is the only cranky I like because he just works with that low voice. I dunno, it just sounds weird coming out of anyone else, imo.

And by that I mean he's the only aesthetically pleasing cranky that works with the low voice. Cesar looks like he'd have a low voice too, but.. he's.. Cesar.

I guess Chief is another good cranky I'd like. ^^

 

[MonoSpectator]

Hmm, ok I think my list is starting to narrow down a bit now ^^

Right now, here are the permanent spots:
1. Fang
2. Beau
3. Lucky
4. Chevre
5. Rosie
6. Ankha
7. Marshal
8. Jock Villager
9. Uchi Villager
10. -Free Space-

So, three spots are open...two being reserved for a jock and uchi and the other open to any personality type. While I love Bob, I don't like that he's another lazy XD That would put me with three, so I'd like to have one of a different Type than lazy for that extra spot ^^

 

[Xintetsu]

I'd choose Pashmina for uchi and Snake for jock.

 

[ayeeprill]

I'd go with:

Fang
Bob!
!!!!RIBBOT!!!!
Eugene
Blanche
Chevre
Flora or Tangy
Pashmina

- - - Post Merge - - -

And you could always have a "rotating" villager space, too, in case you get attached to a camper or find one on a cycling thread you're drawn to for some reason.

 

[MonoSpectator]

Thanks everyone for your inputs! I think I've got the line-up all set!