Can you only have one special character on your island at a time?

[mowglibowgli]

I had Flick on my island all day today... and then Celeste came and I can't find him anywhere Is this supposed to happen?

-MowgliBowgli

 

[Azrael]

You can have multiple! He should still be around somewhere.

 

[lPeachy]

Yeah you can def have multiple, he’s just hiding!

 

[mowglibowgli]

You can have multiple! He should still be around somewhere.

Thanks! I eventually found him but I had to save and then re-enter the game and he was in plain sight, in case you ever find this issue!