Can Redd have 4 fakes for sale?

[mousehole]

Redd's in my plaza and according to the thonky guide all 4 items are fakes. Since Thonky shows the actual picture/statue and I've checked and rechecked against the real deal all of them are duds. I thought one of them had to be real. O.O

 

[Ettienne]

Nope. At the least, 2 are fake. At most all four.

 

[MightyMunchlax]

I've never had it happen but that doesn't mean it isn't possible? Which ones do you have?

 

[mousehole]

The motherly statue - that one's easy because it's missing a child. The dynamic painting is also an easy one because the mountain is very big. The Jolly painting has green under the nose - that's the man made of vegetables and the great Statue looks like the fingers are pointing straight out.

 

[Cobber]

That is a good question. Could be possible I would think

 

[Fantasyland]

It's definitely happened to me multiple times.

 

[FireNinja1]

I don't believe that that's ever happened to me before. All of times I visited Redd, Thonky informed me that at least one of them was real.

 

[Hypno KK]

I don't think so, everything I've read and the clues in the game indicate that there's always about 3 fakes but not 4. Maybe you're just mistaking one of them for a fake?

 

[dahlialia]

The fingers are pretty much straight out on both versions of the great statue. One has them slightly up, the other slightly down. The palm is what to look at - the palm up is real

I find this site best because it has photos of both the real and fake http://bidoofcrossing.tumblr.com/post/40664617166/crazy-redd

 

[ThePayne22]

I've had all 4 fake, so yeah.

 

[mousehole]

The fingers are pretty much straight out on both versions of the great statue. One has them slightly up, the other slightly down. The palm is what to look at - the palm up is real

I find this site best because it has photos of both the real and fake http://bidoofcrossing.tumblr.com/post/40664617166/crazy-redd

Oh that's an excellent site! So it's the Great Statue that is real, it think. lol Welp I'll take my chance - it's only Bells.

 

[Elise]

That's never happened to me either but I guess it must be possible if others have experienced it.

 

[Ettienne]

Oh that's an excellent site! So it's the Great Statue that is real, it think. lol Welp I'll take my chance - it's only Bells.

Let us know if it was! That way we get a concrete answer. c:

Personally I've had four fakes a few times, but I'd like to hear your experience.

 

[Frozen]

I never knew you could have four fakes! The only time I've experienced something other than 1 real and 3 fakes is when I had 2 real.

 

[Arabelle]

After reading this thread, I just checked Redds tent in my town... and all 4 of them are fake... woah.
Never happened to me before....xP
well I honestly doubted when I read some posts about all 4 being fake, but not anymore. It's really possible XD

 

[Story]

Yes, and it has happened to me before.
That darn, dirty fox. :I

 

[Feloreena]

I never realised this could happen, I thought there was always meant to be at least one real piece of art! Glad I know now, but I still think it sucks.