Bring in Toby or keep Marshal?

[TheEchoTimes]

I love Marshal, I really do! But I just haven't had that same, SUPER strong connection with him like I've had with Chops and Julian. But I really like him!
But I'm also thinking about replacing him with Toby... Toby looks cute and has such cute furniture, and he's Sanrio like Etoile and Chai, both of whom live in my town already...
So help me decide! Which do you prefer and why? As with my previous poll, please put both a poll vote and a good (not just the name, but an explanation of your choice as well) thread comment!
I already know that one person on here will be voting for Marshal... We all know who she is~~~

 

[BrinaLouWho]

I personally would chose Toby, he is much more unique and like you said you don't have a strong connection to marshal.

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

You rang? XD

 

[TheEchoTimes]

You rang? XD

Holy crap that was quick.

 

[watercolorwish]

toby!!!!! hes so cute!! i love bunnies theyre one of my fav villager species. his design is also really cute.

marshals time is over. TOBY REVOLUTION

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

Lol I'm flattered that I'm so famous around here.

 

[TheEchoTimes]

Lol I'm flattered that I'm so famous around here.

Well, your name IS ThatOneMarshal fangirl, haha.
I thought, while typing out my post, "Hey, that chick who loves Marshal will probably put in her vote first thing." And lo and behold, you did!

 

[Corrie]

If you don't feel a connection to Marshal, I'd say ditch him tbh.

 

[AccfSally]

Toby,


everyone and their families have Marshal..I can name 80 towns or 200 towns that have him, including my main town. But he's only there because I love all the squirrel villagers.

But I know he's going to get the most votes because of 'how cute and an Irreplaceable he is', Marshal might be in the next AC game while Toby may not be. but whatever

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

Everyone probably thinks I'm a furry. I promise I'm not!

 

[MoeLover]

tbh Marshal is totally irreplaceable!

 

[TheEchoTimes]

Everyone probably thinks I'm a furry. I promise I'm not!

Ohoho~ Of course not~ But I understand the pure, unadulterated love one has for their favorite villager. I had that for Alice, but eventually, she was asking to move almost every day, so I had to let her move...

 

[TheEchoTimes]

bump~

 

[hamster]

Personally, I would pick Marshal because I dislike Toby. However maybe you could replace Marshal and if you realise you prefer him more than Toby, perhaps you can get him back?

 

[Pookie4557]

I had Marshal in my town and I didn't like him. If you don't feel a strong connection to him then I would go with Toby.

 

[HopeForHyrule]

I know everyone loves Marshal. I had him in my old town, but eventually let him move into my husband's town. And now I have Toby in my newest town and I absolutely LOVE him. Not only are the rabbits my favorite of the villager species, but his furniture is amazing and he's adorable!

And I'd you don't feel a very strong connection to Marshal, I say give Toby a chance.

 

[Bcat]

If you have marshall's amiibo too, then heck yeah! Give Toby a chance

 

[TheEchoTimes]

Personally, I would pick Marshal because I dislike Toby. However maybe you could replace Marshal and if you realise you prefer him more than Toby, perhaps you can get him back?

FINALLY THE REPLY INTERFACE LOADED
Anyways... I do indeed have Marshal's amiibo card, so I can get him back if need be. (This reply can also go towards that person with the cat...superhero(?)...guy in their signature because I do NOT feel like trying to get the reply interface to load again to edit my comment with a quote for their comment...)

 

[TheEchoTimes]

boop~
Also, I'll be scanning Toby in tomorrow if I'm having him move in, so tomorrow will be the last comment: the post count! Hurry up and get your votes in, you lovely guys and gals!

 

[JSS]

If you don't feel a connection to Marshal, I'd say ditch him tbh.

This. But since I never had either of them if it was me I'd pick Marshal because I think he's cuter.