Wait, so giving them presents only counts when friendship is already high? And wrapping them also doesn't help unless it's a birthday gift? Maybe that's why my girlfriend can't get the last reaction from Flip... she's starting to really hate him because she wants to move him out but only after getting all the jock reactions first, and she never liked him to begin with, but she's repeatedly giving him gifts and has tried wrapping them too and he won't give it. If giving them presents doesn't increase friendship unless it's already high then that seems odd to me, but would explain it I guess.