Best girl personality for my 10th villager?

[magicalcow]

Hi guys!

So, backstory: with the exception of my BFF Rizzo who I brought in via an Amiibo card, all of my villagers have been random move-ins. I've gotten super attached to all of them & would never dream of asking anyone to leave. The current blend of personalities works great; everyone has at least one close friend, nobody's getting into fights, and we're all one big, happy island community.

Now that my terraforming's done, it's finally time for my 10th villager to move in. I would normally go the random route, but I'm terrified that I'm going to wind up with someone who'll throw off our whole groove. That's where I need your help! Based on the list below, what girl personality would you recommend for my 10th neighbor?

Reneigh - Sisterly
Curly - Jock
Tammi - Peppy
Herb - Lazy
Coco - Normal
Zell - Smug
Gonzo - Cranky
Rizzo - Cranky
Ketchup - Peppy

I don't need a specific villager recommendation 'cause I would like to preserve some element of randomness/surpise, but if you have a favorite character who you think would be a good fit, I'd love to hear about them! Thanks in advance for all your help!

 

[Xara]

based off of your other villagers, i would maybe either go with a snooty or uchi villager. if you’re open to suggestions, some of my personal faves include diana, whitney, fuchsia, cherry and pashmina

 

[Braixen]

I also suggest a snooty since you don't have one!
Some recipes/reactions can only be learned from specific personality types, so you'd be missing out on some without a snooty!

 

[magicalcow]

Wow, snooty won by a landslide! I think y'all are right, she'll get along great with my cranky pals. I've been island hopping with the hope that I'll run into Tipper somewhere along the way. I have a thing for cows, so it kinda seems like it's meant to be.

Thanks again for all the votes + super helpful comments!

 

[JKDOS]

I was going to say normal, but you are lacking a snooty, so this shouldn't even be a question. You need a snooty.

Go for Ankha or Vivian

Snootys are not cranky, so don't worry about that. They are actually quite nice and polite

 

[Jared:3]

Definitely a snooty, Ankha and Diana are the most popular snooty villagers!

 

[Keepitcosmic]

no one ever mentions claudia, but she’s my favorite snooty!! i had never even heard of her until she randomly moved in to my island and she’s the cutest/sweetest ever! her toe beans are purple!!

 

[Saga]

I agree - you absolutely need a snooty! There's a lot to be said for having new dialogue, plus they supposedly give you unique DIYs and reactions.

 

[jreamgardner]

if u do snooty either diana or judy !

 

[magicalcow]

Snootys are not cranky, so don't worry about that. They are actually quite nice and polite

But I love my cranky guys! Rizzo's my favorite villager of all time, we go way back.

 

[axo]

I think snooty is the most interesting personality, dialogue wise, by far. Normal/sweet and peppy are far behind, with uchi kind of in the middle. (In my opinion)