I voted Stitches. As an adult who still cuddles with a teddy bear at night, and loves stuffed animals... he and Drago are my favorite lazy boys from New Leaf.
[That isn't a joke, I got this one teddy bear the day I was born and I need him to sleep well. Like, once I woke up and couldn't find him- which always makes me anxious- but fell back asleep anyway. had a nightmare immediately after. This teddy bear means a lot to me. I turn 29 this September. Adults cuddling with stuffed animals isn't a big deal imo, because I am one. Anyway...]
I count myself lucky because Marshal moved into my original New Leaf town before I started using this forum and saw how popular he was. I was able to form my own "bond" if that makes sense, without knowing how sought-after he was for being cute or cool etc.
Which is really good, bc I love Marshal and quickly grew attached to him, but I know myself. And I KNOW that if I saw his popularity online without having him in my town already, my inner contrarian would have grown to hate him LOL