Any top tier villagers that you just 'don't get'?

[Panduhh]

I don't get why Marshal, the octopi, OR merengue are popular. Okay, Merangue is pretty cute just not for me. My boyfriend at one point wanted Marshal and I just looked at him like >_> and then he strangely changed his mind xD We DO currently have Marshal in the cycling town and he wont leave. I would almost Pay someone TO take him if I could. But alas, tis not aloud.

 

[Klauser_Bateson]

People like him because their subconscious knows he Justin Bieber in-game. I want him so I can abuse him. And Hazel wants to abuse him. We want to destroy the ugly squirrel.

LAUGHING OUT LOUD. I don't care about Marshal whatsoever, but to call him ugly then mention unibrow girl, who's uglier than he is? K.


Diana and Whitney are the only tier 1 villagers I actually like. The rest of them are just okay, with some looking really bland (Marshal, Fauna), and others looking really hideous (Julian, the octopi). And although I have Stitches in my town right now and like him a lot, I can see why people wouldn't like him either. I remember not being that into him when he first moved in.

Tier 2 has a lot more villagers I like than tier 1, but there are a few that I absolutely don't care for (Chrissy, Coco, and Tia to name a few). What baffles me about tier 2 is how Pietro got to be that high. I didn't expect him to be so popular. I saw him in a dream town and told myself that if he ever came to live in my town I would quit the game. I find him to be one of the worst looking villagers, down there with Barold and the gorillas.

 

[MayorErin]

I'm not a huge fan of the Chrissy, Francine, Octavian, or Bruce. I mean to each his own but whatever. I also don't see the obsession with Marshal; he looks pretty mean haha, his face would annoy me. I think Hazel is hideous too haha

 

[Boo_is_dead]

Lolly and Beau. There isn't anything special about their design or house (okay I admit Beau's house is kinda cute, if it wasn't for that Mountain Song), I don't even find them cute.

 

[Brackets]

I don't get Merengue because I think her horn looks weird and creepy like she's stabbed someone with it

 

[Mylin]

Merengue, Ankha, & the octopus villagers.

 

[Candy83]

Which top tier (or really popular) villagers (if any) do you find overrated? For me, I find Merengue and Marshall to be highly overrated.

A good example for me is the Lazy deer Beau. I don't deny he appeals to people. He didn't impress me.

When you look at Hound00med's lists of popular villagers, and if you have ever had almost all of them (or, in fact, all of them), you have to note that you cannot expect yourself to genuinely appreciate all of the 15 villagers who rank in the Top Tier. At least one has to fall by the wayside.

I have never had Diana, Marina, or Whitney in any of my towns. (However they're lately ordered.) I can't say anything about them. But, from the rest of the list, I have had all villagers in my three active towns. And the one I didn't care for was Beau.

 

[Bear_Crossing]

Ankha... I used to like her a lot, but she slowly began to annoy me.

 

[Keyblade]

I can see how people would like all of them.
They really are all cute and unique.
Yes, some of the lower tier villagers are underrated, however.

 

[JayTrain]

I can't wait for everyone on this thread to hate me but I just don't get marshall ._.

 

[Alette]

I never liked the rhinos, but I can see why people like Merengue, because she's special in the fact that she's based around food. She's the best rhino in my opinion, but I don't like her that much.
Marshall is obvious to me - he's sassy, he looks a little annoyed, but he's like a little marshmallow, and he's cute, right?
Diana is liked because she fits the snooty personality quite well, she seems a little spoilt and her colour scheme is quite easy on the eye, whilst also being feminine and looking upper class.

 

[MadisonCrossing]

Julian. What's so great about him, besides the fact that he's a unicorn? He wears makeup for Pete's sake. He looks like a guy trying to be a girl...no offense to guys that might wear makeup. But Julian actually doesn't look that good with it.

 

[Yay Sweets]

Diana. She looks like a real... well, snooty. (Avoiding cursing!) I don't really like snooties, personally. Like in real life!

 

[LunaLight]

Lolly. She looks like a normal freakin' cat. So what? I don't see what's so special about her. She's not even cute..

 

[riummi]

Maple and lolly

 

[rose star]

Marshal. I just don't like his frowny face, and I'm not big on squirrel villagers in the first place.

 

[Punchyleaf]

Tbh I don't really get the hype over Julian. Yes, I know he's a unicorn, and that he's "fabulous" or something lol but he's just like another horse to me. Only with a horn. I have him in one town and the only reason I keep him around is because he looks cute with Annalise and he has a nice color palette to him. Other than that, I much prefer Jacques and Chadder

 

[Brendino]

I really don't care for the octopi villagers. Not only do I not care for their looks, but the fact that they can live on land doesn't make any sense at all. Heck, you can even fish for squid!

 

[ellemacc]

Octavian. Marina and Zucker I can understand but he just looks like a pouty little kid???

 

[Tessie]

I don't get Merengue o_o but I don't really like rhinos, they're head is too big, and to see their emotions you gotta talk to them to their side.

I also don't get Beau, or any other deers besides Diana. Do people find deers ridiculous cute? Idk lol. I think Diana is cute only because of her pastel cute dreamy looking colors, thats all.