Another attempt at a sig

[SilentHopes]

V1

I really only liked the background...


V2

It's not the best in the world, but probably the best one I've done... I finally figured out how to use c4d's

Note: You know, now that I look at this, Sora does seem like he just stands out.

 

[lightningbolt]

eh.

 

[Elliot]

I'm not a fan of the text that much... ;P

 

[SilentHopes]

I'm not a fan of the text that much... ;P

Which one?

 

[bittermeat]

Most of the effects do not go well together. It does not really have a focal.
About the size, it kind of makes my eyes wander about.

 

[Yokie]

I like the effects, 9/10.

 

[DirtyD]

4/10. The text ruined the signature. When making a signature, if you can't get the text right, you simply leave it out. Bad text can completely ruin a sig.

 

[Elliot]

I'm not a fan of the text that much... ;P

Which one?

Kingdom Hearts, And the valor Forme thing.
The sora one looks great though.

 

[SilentHopes]

I like the effects, 9/10.

*faints* that's the best I've ever got.

@ whoever said the effects didn't go well together

I thought they did, red, orange, and yellow, that's what I based it off...

 

[DirtyD]

Those are the colors. The colors are fine, but they are talking about the effects themselves.

 

[Josh]

4/10.
It's okay, not excellent.
But it just looks like you got c4d's and put effects as the background and put sora in it, It needs to blend in.
But the c4d/background and effects are actually good.

 

[kierraaa-]

I kinda like it!

 

[bittermeat]

@ whoever said the effects didn't go well together

I thought they did, red, orange, and yellow, that's what I based it off...

I meant the effects themselves.

The mirrored effects near the text throws the whole thing off. The C4Ds on the right side look nice, but it does not correspond with the mirrored effects. They make Sora look awkward.

 

[SilentHopes]

4/10.
It's okay, not excellent.
But it just looks like you got c4d's and put effects as the background and put sora in it, It needs to blend in.
But the c4d/background and effects are actually good.

Thanks. Like I've said very many times in the past, I'm not very good at doing sigs, and I try my best to make it look good, but I don't get much practice, do to people coming in and going something like:

"This is terrible! 1/10"

And that tends to dampen my spirits...

 

[NikoKing]

4/10. The text ruined the signature. When making a signature, if you can't get the text right, you simply leave it out. Bad text can completely ruin a sig.

Oh yeah, and there's no apparent depth at all. The effects are so random and out of place and don't correspond with Sora at all, try and make it so he blends in and not look like you just pasted him on.

 

[SilentHopes]

4/10. The text ruined the signature. When making a signature, if you can't get the text right, you simply leave it out. Bad text can completely ruin a sig.

Oh yeah, and there's no apparent depth at all. The effects are so random and out of place and don't correspond with Sora at all, try and make it so he blends in and not look like you just pasted him on.

I just downloaded some effects that were the same color, and made sure the heart was behind sora, and sora was in front...

@DirtyD

The sig was missing something without text, and I just so happened to have a KH2 font.

 

[NikoKing]

4/10. The text ruined the signature. When making a signature, if you can't get the text right, you simply leave it out. Bad text can completely ruin a sig.

Oh yeah, and there's no apparent depth at all. The effects are so random and out of place and don't correspond with Sora at all, try and make it so he blends in and not look like you just pasted him on.

I just downloaded some effects that were the same color, and made sure the heart was behind sora, and sora was in front...

@DirtyD

The sig was missing something without text, and I just so happened to have a KH2 font.T

Thing is though, the heart isn't really behind Sora, and even if it was it would still ruin the main depth of it.

See, depth is a pretty key element in sig making, since it helps point out the focal point in any kind of signature.

http://www.sigtutorials.com/tutorials/basics/creating-depth-in-your-signatures.html
You might want to take a look at this to get a little better understanding of depth, I think it shows it pretty well. The thing with the effects, is that they're great, but the heart image ruined the flow of them.

 

[Bacon Boy]

You've done a lot better. 4/10

 

[Josh]

4/10.
It's okay, not excellent.
But it just looks like you got c4d's and put effects as the background and put sora in it, It needs to blend in.
But the c4d/background and effects are actually good.

Thanks. Like I've said very many times in the past, I'm not very good at doing sigs, and I try my best to make it look good, but I don't get much practice, do to people coming in and going something like:

"This is terrible! 1/10"

And that tends to dampen my spirits...

No Problem, For some reason I never like rating a signature 1/10.