Here's my general list.
Love/Recommend: Mekakucity Actors and Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun. I know those seem too recent and possibly shallow, but I've been following the songs and/or manga of each for a long time before they were animated.
Like/Recommend: I've watched other pleasant shows, like Haikyuu!, FMA:B, OHSHC, Hyouka (I like this one a lot, but then again, that's probably because it's basically Mekakucity Actors), and Lovely Complex
Tolerate: Chuunibyou demo Koi ga ****ai! (Love, Chuunibyou, & Other Delusions; lol it censored that), Tamako Market (too cutesy; I don't feel like the characters have any personality), ok a lot KyoAni things. Their animation is just beautiful, but I don't like some of the content.
Hate/Would not recommend: Sword Art Online (I didn't realize it was harem until it was too late. I don't like harem. This one's my fault), Free! (except Rin), Shingeki no Kyojin (I like Mikasa and also Eren sometimes, but other than that it moves way too slowly for me. Also I've heard some bad things about the creator? I just can't stand this series anymore.) and of course many others that I have not watched and so aren't relevant here.
New/In progress: NHK ni Youkoso! (it's interesting, but might get too intense for me. We'll see.), Durarara! (I really like it. I mean to finish watching it and the other series in the same universe someday.)