animal crossing goal
- Thread starter Louise_
- Start date
I have Reneigh and Sherb.
I'm going to keep Reneigh because she's a cool uchi. I also like that she has the play hobby and every time I'm running somewhere, she runs right into me like a runaway train. Sherb, I mean he's cute but I don't think he'd survive on a murder pirate island. Once I get his photo, he is free to sail away.
I'm going to keep Reneigh because she's a cool uchi. I also like that she has the play hobby and every time I'm running somewhere, she runs right into me like a runaway train. Sherb, I mean he's cute but I don't think he'd survive on a murder pirate island. Once I get his photo, he is free to sail away.
nerfeddude
Legendary Intellectual
All 5? But aren't there, like, 8 of them? Either way, I have Audie, and I love her to the bits. She's, probably, my favorite peppy.
Yeah there’s 8 new villagers, one for every personality type.
I have Audie, Judy, and Sherb on my island and love all three of them. Audie and Judy are definitely permanent residents.
I had Dom before as well, but just recently let him move away. He was really cute, but just didn’t really click with him.
I have Audie, Judy, and Sherb on my island and love all three of them. Audie and Judy are definitely permanent residents.
I had Dom before as well, but just recently let him move away. He was really cute, but just didn’t really click with him.
Pintuition
Semi IA <3
I have Sherb, Raymond, and Dom. I like Dom and Sherb the best but I haven't decided whether or not to keep Raymond and Sherb permanently yet. Honestly they're a lot like all the other villagers, some I like better than them, some the new ones are better. I'd say a few or half new would probably be cool! So 5ish! Then you can cycle through and experience other villagers too!
Underneath The Stars
거기 너 i fancy you
poor the other 3 always overlooked lmao
I have Judy, Raymond and Sherb. Judy's eyes creeped me out at first but I grew to like her design and she's so sweet so she's definitely a permanent villager. I like Raymond's personality but don't really like his design so after I get his photo I'll probably let him go to make room for villagers I like more. Sherb just moved in so I'm not sure yet, he was really cute and a hoot when I talked to him at the campsite but just worried his dialogue will be too similar to Stitches who is my favourite and permanent villager.
rofl I'm guessing OP forgot Megan, Cyd and... Reneigh?
HollySeeker
Senior Member
I had Megan on my island as one of my original 5. She is adorable and I liked her. I let her go though because Wolfgang was at my campsite and after going through the process to try and get rid of a different villager I got annoyed at how long it was taken so agreed when he said her because I already had two other normals on my island.
I only have Audie and Judy and they're both my dreamie so I'm very happy to have them! The last new villager that I actually really want to get is Raymond just to understand the hype around him but my island is already full so... Maybe if he visits my campsite then I'll kick someone out from the 10 villagers I already have (note all of them are already a dreamie of mine so that' be hard to decide lol)
Nunnafinga
Senior Member
I have Audie,Dom,Sherb,Raymond,Cyd,Reneigh and Judy.The only one I adopted from another island was Cyd.All of the others delivered themselves via the campsite,Nook island or as a starter.
IridianSky
Senior Member
I had Audie as my starter peppy, but let her move out as soon as she asked. She was alright, but honestly I liked other peppy designs a lot more, and she was constantly working out, which I didn’t love.
Currently I have Sherb who I got when a friend let him move out, Raymond who was a random campsite visitor, and Reneigh who I found on a nook island after my original sisterly Renee moved out.
I like them all, and will probably hang onto Raymond long term. I like him more than I thought I woukd. But Sherb and Reneigh I’ll have to see. I don’t think either are going to be my favorites of their personality types.
I mean honestly for me all the villagers of each personality type pretty much act exactly the same with only slight differences like how Audie seemed to work out a lot for someone who wasn’t a jock, but if I were to close my eyes, talking to Audie feels the same as talking to Ruby (current Peppy) or to any other peppy. So for me interacting with the villagers a bit in person tells me if I like their design, and if I like way design and personality mesh.
So yeah, basically things just came down to me not really liking Audie‘s design, but liking Sherb, Reneigh, and Raymond’s designs.
Currently I have Sherb who I got when a friend let him move out, Raymond who was a random campsite visitor, and Reneigh who I found on a nook island after my original sisterly Renee moved out.
I like them all, and will probably hang onto Raymond long term. I like him more than I thought I woukd. But Sherb and Reneigh I’ll have to see. I don’t think either are going to be my favorites of their personality types.
I mean honestly for me all the villagers of each personality type pretty much act exactly the same with only slight differences like how Audie seemed to work out a lot for someone who wasn’t a jock, but if I were to close my eyes, talking to Audie feels the same as talking to Ruby (current Peppy) or to any other peppy. So for me interacting with the villagers a bit in person tells me if I like their design, and if I like way design and personality mesh.
So yeah, basically things just came down to me not really liking Audie‘s design, but liking Sherb, Reneigh, and Raymond’s designs.
I have Raymond(campsite). I like him and I'll keep him for now. I saw Sherb on a mystery island but I was looking for other villagers, I may take him if I come across him again. Dom looks really cute I'd like to find him.
Yep! I got Dom and Judy from mystery islands using 160+NMTs combined for the two which is already a low amount compared to buying them.
I also got Raymond from the campsite luckily enough even though I wasn’t actively looking for him.
Right now, I’m not really in a hurry to get villagers I would consider as permanent island residences as I want to get more villager photos first.
I also got Raymond from the campsite luckily enough even though I wasn’t actively looking for him.
Right now, I’m not really in a hurry to get villagers I would consider as permanent island residences as I want to get more villager photos first.
Your Local Wild Child
Matty the smarting-nosed “reindeer”
I have Audie on both of my islands for a reason. She’s my favorite peppy villager! She’s so doofy for a wolf and I love her for it. She also fits seamlessly on my woodland island since she’s a fox.
I ran into Reneigh on a mystery island tour and passed on her because I thought I needed a smug (ended up paying 30 NMTs for Julian through Nookazon). Turns out I actually needed an Uchi/Big Sister (trying to get all the reactions), as Rodney was on my island for a good amount of time.
My goal is to get all the golden tools, and donate every item to the museum.
My goal is to get all the golden tools, and donate every item to the museum.
JellyBeans
only half awake
I'd love to have Megan at some point and perhaps Sherb too, the others I probably wouldn't turn away if they showed up on a mystery island if I was getting desperate but they're not my first choices. i had reneigh on my very first island on a diff switch and she was quite cute! didn't get a ton of time with her though
Similar threads
- Poll
