According to Gameinformer ...

[Tyeforce]

Tye seriously, you take opinions to a level they don't need to go, you don't need to say "I can't say the best game of all time", just say "these are my favorite games" or even just say "best Mario games are:" it's not like your saying it's fact, it's your opinion.

I know, but there are people here who will use anything I say against me to try to make me look like a hypocrite. I'm just trying to avoid that. (And I really can't decide, lol.)

 

[bazookie]

its obviously MW2

 

[Zachary]

I disagree.

This.^

 

[Bacon Boy]

Of the Zelda games, The Wind Waker is the best to me.

Same, + Ocarina of Time.

But Zelda II, Link's Adventure, or w/e (the one majorly RPG styled) was IMO terrible... I hated it.

 

[Nic]

Tye seriously, you take opinions to a level they don't need to go, you don't need to say "I can't say the best game of all time", just say "these are my favorite games" or even just say "best Mario games are:" it's not like your saying it's fact, it's your opinion.

I know, but there are people here who will use anything I say against me to try to make me look like a hypocrite. I'm just trying to avoid that. (And I really can't decide, lol.)

Just say your top ten and possibly add that you don't know which game goes first or whatever.

 

[Megamannt125]

@Pyro, what, I was just pointing that out, I don't want to "pwn" anyone.

 

[Neko Yuki Pyrozanryu]

@Pyro, what, I was just pointing that out, I don't want to "pwn" anyone.

-hugs-
you seriously pwned him though :]...
Gaaah i wanna spend hours on msn with you again....damn my father for *censored.3.0*ing the laptop up ;-;

 

[MrChuckman64]

Super Mario Galaxy is the best game of all time.

 

[The Sign Painter]

No, my bro got it on GBA as one of their classic releases, and it sucks.
I used a walkthrough so I could know where the heck I was going, and I got to about the 4th temple thingy before I got bored.
Wind Waker is the best Zelda game I have played so far, and I just started playing it.

 

[Tyeforce]

@Pyro, what, I was just pointing that out, I don't want to "pwn" anyone.

-hugs-
you seriously pwned him though :]...
Gaaah i wanna spend hours on msn with you again....damn my father for *censored.3.0*ing the laptop up ;-;

I don't see how I was "pwn'd" at all. >_>

 

[Megamannt125]

@Pyro, what, I was just pointing that out, I don't want to "pwn" anyone.

-hugs-
you seriously pwned him though :]...
Gaaah i wanna spend hours on msn with you again....damn my father for *censored.3.0*ing the laptop up ;-;

I don't see how I was "pwn'd" at all. >_>

Neither do I.

 

[muffun]

Can't say I agree with this.

 

[Vivi]

I think Ocarina of Time is the best game of all time

 

[Kanye Omari West]

I disagree.

The best NES game would be SMB, or the two Punch-Outs.

 

[VantagE]

To many many Zelda fans OoT is the best of the best. And I would have to agree, though my second would be TP, I just had an overall blast playing that one. Majora is good but eh not my favorite. IF we are going for an older Zelda, like before OoT, I would say A Link to the Past.

 

[djman900]

Of all time? If I were to pick a zelda game its be majoras mask. Of all time I'd have to go with Oblivion

 

[Yokie]

Of all time? If I were to pick a zelda game its be majoras mask.

This.

 

[quincify]

Can't say I agree with this.

.

 

[VantagE]

OoT beats Majoras Mask any day.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

How many lifelong gamers did Shigeru Miyamoto's masterpiece create? How many developers - many of them legends in their own right - cite The Legend of Zelda as a beloved inspiration? It's diffacult to overstate its impact on the development of video games as entertainment, art, and cultural phenomena. On a mechanical level, very few games to this date can claim such a perfect fusion of elements as diverse as exploration, collection, puzzle solving, combat, and storytelling. From a right-brain perspective, few works capture the transcendent spirit of whimsy and adventure that The Legend of Zelda effortlessly expresses. Ahead of its time by years if not decades, Zelda is responsible for significant chunks of design that we take for granted in nearly every genre. We all owe a great debt as gamers to Miyamoto and everyone else at Nintendo who made this title possible. The Legend of Zelda is no less than the greatest game of all time.

Super Mario Bros. at #2 and Tetris at #2. Half Life 1 and 2 made the cut, Left 4 Dead 1, ALttP, Super Mario 64, couple of Final Fantasies, Mike Tyson's Punch Out, MW1, Chrono Trigger, OoT comes in at #20, (personal favorite) Galaga at 23, Sonic the Hedgehog 1 and 2, Mega Man 2, Pokemon R/B, most(if not all) MGS games, Uncharted 2 at 56, Link's Awakening and Majora's Mask at 61 and 63, and of course a bunch of other games. (TF2 at #118)

I'll agree with the original LoZ deserving the top spot, can't say Super Mario Bros would of inspired as many people to become game developers or continue gaming.

EDIT: Oh yeah, Earthbound is #113.