What’s the best villager you’ve turned down on a mystery island?

[Rosewater]

Best one I've had to pass was Norma. All my good villagers were random move ins.

 

[th8827]

After the guy who promised me Marshal yesterday was a no-show, I went Island Hopping to find a replacement.

I found Octavian twice. He is a Dreamie, but I already have Fang, and I decided that I only wanted 1 Cranky villager, so I had to turn him down...