I like Penny best - she didn't make it past the Gamecube games but she was one of my neighbours in that town. I liked her a lot. Also the fact she makes an appearance in 'The Terrible Secret of Animal Crossing' story, if any of you have read that
Rod has been with me for many years in the Animal Crossing games, I even bought his amiibo just so he would be in my new leaf town with me. I love a lot of the mice but he is my favorite. Ace. ^^
Rod and Chadder have a special place in my heart as Chadder was a starter and Rod was the first villager to ever move in! Their houses are also right by each other which is really cute because they've become best friends. Dora also has a special place in my heart because her house is kinda dorm-esque and I'm struggling with college rn so I relate to her. She's also just super cute and sweet.
I voted for Anicotti because I had her in City Folk and she is really nice. I also like Chadder because his design is pretty funny and he has a cool house.