Would you rather have Marshal or W Link

[DaviddivaD]

I currently have W Link in my town. I had to kick Ken the smug chicken out who I've had for over three years now. But I thought it was time for a change. I'm enjoying W Link but the way he puts new items he gets in his house annoys me for some reason. Putting a piece of furniture directly (which is now a model of the Leaning Tower of Pisa) in front of the Master Sword in his house. Replacing his hay bed with a flat screen TV etc.

I bought a Marshal amiibo card for a very cheap price on eBay and I don't know if I should kick W Link out for him or not.

As for "Why not both?"... the smug personality seems to have more limited dialog than other personalities. If I have to hear about cucumbers on more time...

Other than W Link placing furniture in weird places, I am enjoying him in my town. I love how they got his design down pat. From the designs on his head to the broken chain on his arm.

Would YOU rather have W Link or Marshal?

 

[Jackfrost]

Wolf Link. I just feel like Marshal is overrated

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

I tend to avoid giving villagers furniture, Epona and W Link especially since their houses won't suit too many furniture pieces (I don't think they do anyway).
At the moment I have W Link in my town, the only reason I don't also have Marshal right now is because I also have Toby who is another smug. They're both wondeful, I love smugs. Marshal is adorable but I love LOZ so W Link was necessary for me, particularly since my town is called Hyrule since you have both their amiibos available, why not keep W Link a little longer and then switch to try marshal? Nobody has to be permanent when we have the amiibos. I'm going to keep swapping out villagers to keep things fresh

 

[AccfSally]

W.Link, Marshal isn't that special..I know because I have him.

 

[al-tirah]

For me it's W Link. I kind of like Marshal too but I've seen Marshal in dream towns but I haven't met W Link.

 

[idiotdoomspiral]

marshal is cute. i wouldn't mind keeping him forever. but i prefer w link

 

[Sweetley]

Voted for W. Link, I have him in my town and he's a amazing villager. Never really liked Marshal.

 

[Zireael]

I'll say Wolf Link. Marshal is okay but I've never really understood why he's so popular. He's cute, but I don't really like the idea of a small, cute squirrel having the smug, flirtatious personality. Wolf Link doesn't even suit the personality either, but I'd still prefer him over Marshal when it comes to aesthetics. Wolves are great.

 

[DaviddivaD]

I tend to avoid giving villagers furniture, Epona and W Link especially since their houses won't suit too many furniture pieces (I don't think they do anyway).
At the moment I have W Link in my town, the only reason I don't also have Marshal right now is because I also have Toby who is another smug. They're both wondeful, I love smugs. Marshal is adorable but I love LOZ so W Link was necessary for me, particularly since my town is called Hyrule since you have both their amiibos available, why not keep W Link a little longer and then switch to try marshal? Nobody has to be permanent when we have the amiibos. I'm going to keep swapping out villagers to keep things fresh

I've only given him stuff to hang on his wall. He's been collecting other things by himself.

- - - Post Merge - - -

W.Link, Marshal isn't that special..I know because I have him.

Sorry if this is off topic but I've been wanting to say for a while now. I am a huge fan of your town designs. Very wonderfully done!

 

[TooManyBunnies]

Marshal. I had W. Link in my town for a while, and when he picked up the habit of calling me "dearie" from Skye, it just felt so wrong. Marshal totally could have pulled it off.

 

[HappynessInYou]

I vote for Marshal !

 

[Nezuko]

I'd go with W. Link. Such a nice design on that. He's definitely the kind of Villager I can't see keeping around forever, though. Eventually I'd let him move on.

 

[wolfie1]

I've never been too fond of Marshal to begin with, so I'd pick Wolf Link. I'd also consider having him if I had amiibos, but then I'd have 3 wolves and that's a little bit too much, lol.

 

[Nodokana]

I prefer W. Link. He looks cool.

 

[Xandra]

I don't know what's all the craze about Marshall... I mean, his personality is like any other's and his looks aren't that good for a squirrel. I'd prefer W. Link since he's from another game and it'll feel special having someone like that living in your town, not like Marshall which probably 6/8 towns have.

 

[Capeet]

Wolf Link's got a really cool design so if I was you I'd probably keep him and make him replace his bad decor choices with something more fitting.

 

[HopeForHyrule]

I prefer W. Link, because I love LoZ, his design is pretty much spot on and he's the perfect representation of Oy in my Dark Tower based town.

Marshal is cute, but I've always thought him to be overrated.

 

[ZebraQueen]

Marshal is overated
Plus for me I hate that squirrel....don't ask and it's not from the game

Go for w.link he awesome though he getting pretty popular :/

 

[Sheando]

I've never been crazy about Marshal, but I'd actually prefer him to W. Link. I'm not a fan of mixing fandoms. It feels weird and gimmicky to me to have a Zelda-themed villager in an Animal Crossing game.

 

[hamster]

i like marshal & if i ever got the chance to get him i would but i prefer w.link. i'm not really a fan of zelda but i love his design & the wolves