Which peppt cat villager do yoy recommend?

[Knviess]

I current have Rosie in my island. I wanted to get feedback on which peppy cat villager would be the best recommendation for my current island Mashup. Theme is felines and monsters. I feel such a strong urge to replace her with tangy or tabby. Would like a second opinion on which peppy cat you guys prefer.

Drago
Tucker
Zucker
Marina
Octavian
Leonardo
Leopold
Anka
Katt

 

[Ananas Dragon]

I current have Rosie in my island. I wanted to get feedback on which peppy cat villager would be the best recommendation for my current island Mashup. Theme is felines and monsters. I feel such a strong urge to replace her with tangy or tabby. Would like a second opinion on which peppy cat you guys prefer.

Drago
Tucker
Zucker
Marina
Octavian
Leonardo
Leopold
Anka
Katt

Nooooo keep rosieeeeeeee

but Tangy is nice, she's a good orange

 

[idiotdoomspiral]

tangy is great. id recommend

 

[brockbrock]

I definitely like Rosie the best, but replace her if that's what your heart is telling you!

 

[Blueskyy]

Tangy fits the peppy role well. I actually saw Merry in game and she looks a lot better than she did in past games imo.

 

[Knviess]

Nooooo keep rosieeeeeeee

but Tangy is nice, she's a good orange

I'm so conflicted. Rosie fits the peppy popular vibe. Tangy is food. And I love food based characters. And tabby... well she's kinda ugly kinda cute. I think she's Katts sister lol

 

[Licorice]

Tabby is the best cat villager and no one can change my mind

 

[N a t]

Rosie is great but so are a lot of the other cats. I love Merry and Felicity, Tangy is also amazing. Just so many good cats. Hard to go wrong. Since the theme is felines and Monsters I feel that Tangy would fit your island the best. What's cooler than an anthropomorphic orange cat hybrid?

 

[Cethosia]

Tangy would fit both the felines and monsters theme, if you think about it. She's a tangerine but also a cat. I have her on my island currently, and I often catch her singing and sometimes working out. Maybe because of her singing habit, you could get her to sing some songs fitting the theme you are going for.

Tabby... Can't say I am fond of the design. I don't really think she works for the monster theme, but the grin can be unnerving. I think she shares the same interest as Tangy in music, so she might end up singing a lot as well. Haven't had her though so can't say for sure.

 

[Misuzurin]

If your theme is monsters go with Tabby.

 

[Knviess]

Hey guys thanks all for the feedback. I came to decide that if rosie asks to leave ill give tangy a chance. But for now rosie will stay. I'm over time traveling to remove 1 villager. Anyhow you guys everyone who helped out is welcomed to explore my island! When I say monsters and cats. Its definitely that. Periodt!

 

[kojuuro]

I love Tangy! She was great on my island

 

[Lady Sugarsaurus]

I will always love Felicity, she is the best peppy cat, imo. <3

 

[Knviess]

.

 

[dragonair]

Tangy's cute! You can gift her an orange and she'll eat it. She'll eat the orange.

 

[Knviess]

Tangy's cute! You can gift her an orange and she'll eat it. She'll eat the orange.

Omg the more im hyped about her

 

[senbeiiscool]

Easily Tangy! She's adorable!

 

[Nunnafinga]

Tangy is cute but she also has that weird half orange/half cat thing going which is creepy to some people.I've always thought that her orangeyness(probably not a word)makes her seem to be extra peppy.I have Tabby in New Leaf and I've always liked her but I'd go with Tangy here.There's also the peppy tigers Bangle and Bianca.

 

[Knviess]

Tangy is cute but she also has that weird half orange/half cat thing going which is creepy to some people.I've always thought that her orangeyness(probably not a word)makes her seem to be extra peppy.I have Tabby in New Leaf and I've always liked her but I'd go with Tangy here.There's also the peppy tigers Bangle and Bianca.

I had Bianca before. If you gave her cute clothes her oversized long body doesn't work well with shirts

 

[Rasha]

Tabby.