When asking for Toy Day gifts, Alice and Ankha said food... Does that mean a basket of fruit/mushrooms/candy/etc. or an actual foody furniture item? (Samgyetang, Yule log, turkey, etc.)
Last year, one of the gifts in my Toy Day bag was a piece of fruit. That's probably what your villager wants. Pretty sad, huh? Everyone else wants furniture or a carpet and one villagers asks for fruit...which they could pick off a tree for free. LOL
They'll give you some other hints too! Cheri asked me for something yummy to eat and something red in 2 separate convos :> (sniff, she's moving, so I felt a little guilty hearing her Christmas wish :< )