Im about to re-start in my town for sure, and these are the things Im definitively going to be looking for:
-Re-tail near the docks
-Waterfall pouring into the sea on the south.
-No "mini island" on the beach that is only rechable with the diving suit.
-Town Tree at the center of the map.
-I want the ramp that goes down the beach at the south to face the south, not awkwardly to the side. (If that makes sense to anyone?). Best case scenario involves having it perfectly lined up with the docks!
This is basicaly what I dont like.
-I kinda prefer towns where the sea expands to the left, but Im not too picky on this.