I had T-Bone for longest and regret letting him go. Had Roscoe but he was out of line. I'll work on getting a cranky. They're really quite nice tho they wouldn't admit it!
Haha I love balance so I have each for one personality in my town ^^ and for the extra 2~ I choose cute peppy Bunnie and Lazy Papi! xD Hope you found your cranky soon =)
Smug: 2
Cranky: 2
Normal: 1 or 2
Lazy: 1 or 2
Uchi: 1
Jock: 1
Snooty: +-1
Peppy: +-1
I could deal without having a snooty and or a peppy in my town. Smug and cranky villagers are my favorite if I had a village of 5 each of the personalities I still would never get sick of them.
The only thing I really wish I had was a lazy. Other than that the off balance of my town personalities have never bothered me much. I don't pay too much attention to their dialogue.