To those who are missing out on personalities...

[Globes216]

I’m really struggling to find a jock villager that I really like, it’s always been my least favourite personality and in this game since almost all of them have the fitness hobby it makes them even worse and they always talk about muscles!

If you’re missing a jock (or any other personality) do you feel like you’re missing a lot or do you like not having one? I’m considering ditching my jock and getting another Lazy.
My only issue is I know jocks give unique DIY recipes etc so those who are missing a personality do you feel like you’re missing DIYs or do they come up often enough on the beach etc?

 

[pocky]

jocks also give unique reactions, which you can't trade for with other members or get from the beach (if you care about those)

personally i try to keep at least one of each personality

 

[Jam86]

i have all personalities but i've been thinking about getting rid of my jock and my cranky, the only cranky i like is apollo but my brother has him and i just don't like jocks
i only get them for the reactions since the diys appear on the beach anyway
but now i've got the reactions from them, i don't think there's any point to having a personality i don't like

 

[sleepydreepy]

you could find the best jock you think you would like, and have him on your island temporarily or something! keep him around for the diys and reactions, but if he annoys you then just let him go! he doesn't have to be a permanent resident, just a visitor

 

[Sloom]

im missing a jock too (technically I'm not at the moment, but I'm keeping Dom for the flourish reaction)

since I have a jock on my island right now, I can definitely say I wouldn't feel like I was missing out if I didn't have a jock. I lived without one for about a month and it was honestly nicer not having one around lol. not a fan of the dialogue at all

diys are pretty unimportant, if you really want a particular diy you can easily find it from trading or random beach diys. other than that you're really not missing out. if reactions matter to you, just keep them until you get all of the jock ones!

 

[Globes216]

jocks also give unique reactions, which you can't trade for with other members or get from the beach (if you care about those)

personally i try to keep at least one of each personality

Oh reactions I completely forgot about those! Maybe I’ll keep a temporary one then just to get them all

 

[sunchild]

i'm missing out on a snooty, and i will eventually have one move in (and most likely stay) just so i can get all the reactions. the diys they specifically give matters a bit less to me since i can always get them from friends or through trading around.

 

[PaperCat]

I am missing snooty and smug. i plan on getting them when i can get 2 others to move.

 

[Fendi]

I'm actually missing a snooty and a cranky personality. I guess it was my mistake for letting Soleil go, but I'll have to wait until someone asks to move out as I prefer not to time travel.

I wish I had known sooner that different personalities gave unique reactions and DIYs, I was starting to wonder why it felt like I was getting the same DIYs over and over again. But I'll just wait until then!

 

[Ananas Dragon]

I’m really struggling to find a jock villager that I really like, it’s always been my least favourite personality and in this game since almost all of them have the fitness hobby it makes them even worse and they always talk about muscles!

If you’re missing a jock (or any other personality) do you feel like you’re missing a lot or do you like not having one? I’m considering ditching my jock and getting another Lazy.
My only issue is I know jocks give unique DIY recipes etc so those who are missing a personality do you feel like you’re missing DIYs or do they come up often enough on the beach etc?

I don't have a Jock or a cranky (that's staying anyway)
and I could care less if the personality didn't exist
I'm already struggling to let my villagers go, it's going to take everything I have to let marina go but it has to be done I have 7 girls and 3 boys i need to invite marshal

 

[Lattecakes]

I am missing a snooty atm and have been struggling to get one. I never come across a snooty on my island hops except once and it was Whitney. She seems awesome but I would like Diana, Ankha, or Judy. My campsite also haven't been giving me much luck on my snooty search. It's supposed to have a 60% rate of giving you a personality you don't have, but I keep getting the personalities that I already have living on my island. I really would like a snooty for their reactions and diy.
Also, for not liking a jock, maybe you just haven't found one you like? I know jocks weren't my favorite in NL and I didn't really care for them at the start of NH. Getting Dom by chance changed my mind about jocks. He is super friendly and makes the best meme faces. He never works out (surprisingly lolol). All he does is play with his friends, eat donuts, drink sodas, sit under trees and watch clouds passing by haha. He is a total cutie. Yes, he does talk about muscles and working out sometimes, but the fact that I never see it makes it hilarious to me. Stiches even called him out on his BS once LOL. Stiches demaded to see his 8 pack abs he was telling people about and at the end of the convo, dom revealed secretly that he doesn't have any abs. I died of laughter

 

[pittapotamus]

I'm missing a jock AND a cranky and i really feel like I'm missing something from my island. it was never intentional - I always just came across really cute villagers on NMT islands and couldn't say now. I think I'm a bit more selective when it comes to jocks and crankies though so that's probably why - I think Bam is the only jock I love.

 

[N a t]

I keep one of each personality so that my island feels diverse. You could always keep a jock that you like temporarily for some of the stuff they give you and then boot them! Or maybe look online for interactions and images of the ones you find at least a little cute and see if they grown on ya!

 

[Believe]

I'm missing an uchi because I think they're all ugly and now im regretting letting the forced uchi go before I got all the reactions because I'm literally only missing the top friendship tier one and to think I have to have one on my island and get them to max stage friendship for the reaction is exhausting

 

[cheezu]

I'm currently missing a jock and I actually do feel like I'm missing out BIG time especially being over 2 months into the game.
It didn't bother me that much at first when Rowan moved out but for a while I didn't have a snooty either (3 lazies and 3 crankies). And it did get boring to be put through identical dialogue several times a day plus you won't be able to get all the reactions and will be slower in obtaining recipes (you can still get them from random bottles or through trades but it's definitely a slower process).
I actually think a lot of the jocks are super cute. I'm actually on the lookout for Mac who is a dreamie of sorts when one of my unwanted villagers decides to move out but I'm also open to Scoot, Bill, Tad or Louie.

 

[cinch]

.

 

[baobei]

i'm missing a sisterly/uchi :'( really need to start on inviting one since i've been on the hunt for the apologetic expression that only uchis give out ;;

 

[stiney]

Hamlet is adorable and his hobby is play so he works out less than Cousteau (hobby is fitness). His singing is cursed though (the only two times he's tried to sing in my town it was that glitched high pitched noise instead of cute lil singing).

I'm currently missing a lazy and I feel it. I'm missing almost all of the lazy DIYs and I think most of the 8 reactions I still need are from lazies and smugs (see below).

I let Colton move out, and couldn't find a smug I liked (or at all) on an island before bed and the next morning I had a voided Axel moving in (bringing me to 3 jocks, 0 smugs). So I get Carmen as a campsite villager, and figuring she has a 30% chance of picking a jock to move out. Nope, she kicked my baby Filbert. But okay, I had him in New Leaf and I want to experience new villagers, so away goes Filbert. Then I let Snooty leave, and I again couldn't find a smug or lazy on an island (I went to at least 20--I think I saw *one* lazy but I was really holding out for a smug since I'd been without one for longer), I already have Mathilda so I'll still have a snooty when she goes. Wake up the next day and I have Phil. OK, cool, he's a smug, and I like him. Then Axel decides to leave. Hooray! He is my least favorite of the three jocks! Again, I can't find a lazy on an island. The next morning, I have Chadder, voided from my roommate's girlfriend's island. I did get Drago in my campsite yesterday but I was not a fan and didn't have time to spend resetting to get him to kick a repeat villager.

I'm trying not to use amiibo because I don't want to kick anyone out and I want some element of surprise but I think I might have to scan one in. Maybe I'll use an RNG to pick me a lazy so I still get that element of randomness/surprise. I can scan them in twice and then do the final move in after someone decides to move out...

 

[zato]

very much so atm....my island in mainly cranky, smug, one lazy, one snooty, one normal, and one uchi. i'm thinking of moving out some of my boys so i can get reactions and stuff before i make permanent movements. i have their amiibo so it'll be fine i just hope i have an amiibo of every type...i think i do but idk been a while since i peeked at who i had.

 

[MelodyRivers]

I currently am missing an uchi(sisterly). I started with diva and she just came across as rude to me. She would tell me “is this island not big enough for the both of us” if I talked to her to much. Right now I’m ok without one and I don’t really miss it but then I don’t know what the other uchis are like. That being said, I would like to have at least one of each personality. For variety.