This is a toughie, but someone has to go.

[Dorian]

Kid Cat vs Marina. A fight for the ages. Jock vs Normal. Lots of pink, suckery arms vs two fluffy paws.

And the winner is....

 

[Blueskyy]

I'd say Marina but only because I believe I found the only normals worth caring about in my town. Kid Cat seems to be among the top 3 jocks. I have Rudy for a jock though.

 

[tae]

keep kid cat. he is so so so so so cute. and a superhero i mean come on, how can you not love that?
i had him and i feel bad bc he moved away due to a time travel accident and i would kill to have him back.

 

[Dorian]

Andy, I honestly find the normals a bit dull as well.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Thank you, Tae He is a superhero!

 

[Blueskyy]

I'd say Marina but only because I believe I found the only normals worth caring about in my town. Kid Cat seems to be among the top 3 jocks. I have Rudy for a jock though.

To clarify I meant keep Kid Cat. I had Zucker and found that the octopi were no big deal to my personal tastes.

 

[Two-Face]

I would keep Kid Cat out of those two, but I'm very biased towards cats.

 

[tearypastel]

i would keep kid cat. my sister has him and he is soo cute! i had marina for a bit but i didn't really see the appeal of her. kid cat for the win!

 

[tae]

Andy, I honestly find the normals a bit dull as well.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Thank you, Tae He is a superhero!

i think everyone should have ONE normal in their town, i have mine. (daisy) and i just adore her to pieces even if she's a little dull compared to my snooties, crankies, and lazies alike. but i just, idk im NOT a big jock villager fan (trying to get rid of 1/2 of my jocks bc they just.. no it's too much haha) but kid cat is really one of the most tolerable jock villagers, followed immediately by snake the crazy pink rabbit. <3

 

[Twisterheart]

Keep Kid Cat! He is such a sweetheart.

 

[Blueskyy]

i think everyone should have ONE normal in their town, i have mine. (daisy) and i just adore her to pieces even if she's a little dull compared to my snooties, crankies, and lazies alike. but i just, idk im NOT a big jock villager fan (trying to get rid of 1/2 of my jocks bc they just.. no it's too much haha) but kid cat is really one of the most tolerable jock villagers, followed immediately by snake the crazy pink rabbit. <3

Oh yeah. I dunno if it came of as me hating normals, but they're my favorites. I have 3 (Maple, Molly, and Fauna) and I love them all. I would still have Aurora too but I had to cut her loose. I'm still sad about it.

As far as jocks go I've had Bam and now Rudy and like both. I also had Snake in campsite and he seemed cool. That's it.

 

[roseflower]

Personally I don`t really like Kid Cat in New Leaf, he looked much cuter in Wild World because now the helmet looks weird and those new proportions. So I?d say either keep Marina or look out for another jock, they are really lovely and funny to have around in your town.

 

[Blueskyy]

Seriously though just make Rudy your jock. I love him to pieces haha

 

[gem83]

Ditch Marina. She's overdone imo, and Kid Cat is so awesome and cute! Plus, jocks are the best!

 

[Athelwyn]

Oh, Kid Cat is great! He's so adorable, definitely my favorite jock next to Rudy. Although when I had him in my town, I had to monitor him to make sure he never changed out of his default shirt, since anything else ruins his superhero ensemble.

As for Marina...octopi freak me the heck out, though if I were going to have an octopus in my town, I would choose her.

Kid Cat still gets my vote to stay.

 

[mayortash]

It's a tough call! Truthfully, I would keep whoever had moved in last on this one. I couldn't possibly choose between the two.

 

[HungryForCereal]

keep kid cat. though i like marina, she seems kinda dull and plain with only 1 color. kid cat is soooo cute!

 

[mintellect]

That's tough. Imo the jocks are my least favorite personality, but Kid Cat is cuter than Marina.
Why can you only have one, anyway?

 

[Kittyinpink87]

I would keep Marina. She is such a darling.

 

[Belle of Pripyat]

Unlike most people on this thread, I prefer Marina. I love the pink bow on the back of her head. Kid Cat is someone I would have moved out as soon as possible, though.

 

[edsett]

Keep Marina. Kid Cat is cute and all but there's cuter jocks (Genji lol) and it's kinda awkward to have Kid Cat by himself and not with the other agents imo. Marina is more unique just based on her species.