I'm going to restart later today/early tomorrow, so I'll just start brainstorming some stuff.
Top Priority:
- Town Name: DO NOT START MAP RESETTING UNTIL YOU HAVE DECIDED ON A TOWN NAME. Mayor name too, I guess. Say this out loud a couple times to make sure you remember. I always forget.
- Town Hall: If you want to keep the town hall's original design, you should definitely reset if you get a yellow one. The other colours are all pretty decent and interchangeable, and it really doesn't matter which one you get. Black and green are both neutral colours and will fit well with everything, and although blue is not, it's dark enough to not be a problem. Also, nobody really cares about this but the desk inside the green town hall is green. It's not as bad as it sounds though, so reset
only if the exterior is yellow.
- Town Tree Location: The town tree is the first thing anyone will see when they visit your dream town, so it has to look amazing. Most people like to like it with bushes and trees, but you can't do that if it's close to the edge of town. You will either a) literally not be able to because it's that close or b) be able to, but it'll look gross because you also have a line of trees/bushes bordering the railroad. A central tree is best for map aesthetics, but really anywhere is fine.
- Good Mayor Location: Out of all the buildings, your mayor's house is the most important to place in a good spot. Most maps have a private or semi-private area to put a house, so you will usually (BUT NOT ALWAYS) want to put it there. If a villager's house or rock is blocking the ideal spot, you should probably reset. Yes they're removable and yes you can put a different human resident's house there, but it probably won't be as good because a) you probably want your mayors house by itself and the other two together (fourth doesn't exist) and b) your mayors house is most important anyways. You don't necessarily have to reset though.
Lower Priority:
- Beach Ramps: Horizontal beach ramps are pretty, while vertical ramps are gross. It's usually not worth resetting over, but it's still something to consider if you're unsure whether or not to keep a decent-but-not-great looking town. It's less bad if the vertical ramp is on the side beach though.
- Grass Shape: Circle and square grass don't look as good as triangle grass because they're larger, but they're still okay. This is more of a problem if you want a natural town, since if your town is going to be more developed barely any grass will be poking out. Also iirc snow shapes are random and not related to grass shapes so that can be considered your second chance I guess.
- Town Fruit: Perfect apples are beautiful, cherries and peaches (and pear but no one likes them) are okay and oranges are gross. Having apples is great and awesome, but you're going to have more than one kind of fruit in your town anyways so it doesn't matter that much if you don't have them. Having oranges is pretty annoying though, since you won't have any perfect fruit at all.
- Train Station: The blue train station is disgusting compared to the other ones. You can considering resetting if you get and plan to keep it, but you probably shouldn't.
Who Cares:
- Initial Villagers: The next three move-ins are the best opportunities you will ever have to get the villagers you want (and in the right location, if you care about that). If you have at least one dreamie of each personality type, you will already be guaranteed three within a week, so having an extra one or two isn't too big a deal. There's also tons of cycling threads. DO NOT reset over this. Just don't, okay?
- Left/Right Beach: Determines the museum and bench's location on Main Street too btw. But seriously this is the worst thing ever to reset over.