Restarting Question: As if There weren't Already way too Many of These

[Hamilton]

I recently bought a second copy of ACNL, but I'm really just not feeling it. I've already lost interest in it.
Cons:
I have 6 Dreamies including Jaques, Stitches, and Fauna. I suppose I could have someone hold them.
I have unlocked half of Main Street (Who really cares though)
My town layout is absolutely beautiful; It has a central plaza, and everything aligns with the train station. The tree, the river bend, Stitches' house.
I have Peaches as my Native which happen to be my favorite (That's a lie. Anything that isn't oranges is my favorite)

Pros:
I accidentally named my mayor Color instead of Pastel
I can plot reset to get better villagers (plus I can get Jaques back easily)
I can get better rock placement. They decided to be right in the middle of every open space -_-
I can easily store stuff in my secondary, namely my custom Cabana set
I can landscape better

 

[miraxe]

I think the issues you listed are big enough issues that it's worth resetting for. Even if you don't reset now, you'll probably want to later, and then it'll be even more difficult just because you ended up progressing to a certain point. That actually happened to me, but I'm so glad I reset. Thankfully villager trading is still going strong, so even if you end up not being able to reset for all of the villagers that you want, you can easily buy them. As for the town's layout, you can always find something similar- or even something better! Things like horribly placed rocks aren't so fixable, though. I had a similar issue with rocks being conveniently placed in the exact spot I wanted a PWP. So, so, SO glad I reset and got that problem out of my way. My town looked like a mess.

 

[Hamilton]

Bump! Anyone else?

My problem is that I think I might be able to make what I want, but I'll need to compromise and improvise. I kind of want to restart, but I want to avoid the hassle of moving villagers out, then back in, or transferring between my main and secondary town.

 

[AkaneDeath]

I think you got you titles mixed up? Pros are supposed to be the good things...

Anyway, I think it might be a good thing to reset? You can always get your dreamies held for you and perhaps you'll come up with an even better layout once the rocks are gone!

 

[Red Cat]

It depends on how far you are in to your town. Really, the only things that take a lot of effort to redo are getting PWP requests again and filling your museum. You can transfer any items you want and bells are easy to get especially if you don't care about getting them by buying them with your TBT. Getting your dreamies back may take some searching, but you'll eventually find them again. You can always TT if you don't want to wait for shops to open again.